In one lede, you assumed by saying a 6-year-old girl saved her and her mother's life.
Now,
certainly the mother was being brutally attacked. And the girl was in fear for her safety. Conventional wisdom
gives you the right to label that as just that, in the same way the
girl's actions can be viewed as heroic based on how she dealt with a
horrible situation and how conventional wisdom would view that.
But can you say the mom would have certainly died without the 911 call being made? And do we know for sure the little girl was at risk of death?
I
don't think so. This is a stretch. You can say the girl helped rescue
her mother or helped apprehend her attacker, because those are based on
facts. We simply don't have enough information to judge whether she
would have been killed or just brutalized. There is a huge difference between the two.
Likewise, you can say the girl was terrified and at risk of harm because an attacker was in her home, but not that her life was certainly at risk.
Now, some of you said the girl potentially saved her mother's life (italics mine), or something to that effect. That's more reasonable. Certainly if she is being allegedly raped by a man with a knife, she's at risk of substantially-greater harm.
But we have to be precise in how we couch that. She may be at great risk, but she is not assured of death. Our language needs to make that clear.
In another instance, you made an assumption that the victim was someone the attacker had personally known.
You
did know the victim was the suspect's neighbor, but does that
automatically mean the knew each other? I mean, I don't know my
neighbors. Maybe that's because I'm an asshole, but the rapist doesn't
sound like the nicest neighbor, either.
Again, you're
going a step further than the evidence at hand allows. Either get a
clarification from sources that establishes your premise or back off to a
claim better supported by the facts in hand.
Showing posts with label assumptions. Show all posts
Showing posts with label assumptions. Show all posts
Thursday, February 28, 2013
Tuesday, January 29, 2013
Basic Ledes: Analysis Or Opinion?
It's a fine line between using descriptive words justified by the facts and being sensational with little justification. This lede straddled that line:
There was a miraculous escape as a train struck a family of three's SUV at an unsafe intersection on Michigan Avenue near Wayne Boulevard on Monday afternoon.
First, is it fair to say it was miraculous? It it was your conclusion, probably. But the information you were given included, police said it was amazing no one was killed. So it wasn't you simply making a subjective conclusion; you were citing presumed experts on car crashes (and hopefully in the body of the story you would include a quote from police explicitly supporting that claim in the lede).
Now, was it fair to call the intersection unsafe? This was a bit dicier. The information you were given said there were no warning lights or a crossing gate, but there were warning signs and a stop sign.
So, is that necessarily unsafe? If later in your story you cited some sort of expert or experts (like cops or safety engineers) or other people in the know (frequent users of the intersection), saying it's unsafe and offering a justification of why it's unsafe, then I'd say you're in the right.
But while this is clearly a less-protected crossing, I think it's a leap to say it's unsafe, in lieu of additional information.
There was a miraculous escape as a train struck a family of three's SUV at an unsafe intersection on Michigan Avenue near Wayne Boulevard on Monday afternoon.
First, is it fair to say it was miraculous? It it was your conclusion, probably. But the information you were given included, police said it was amazing no one was killed. So it wasn't you simply making a subjective conclusion; you were citing presumed experts on car crashes (and hopefully in the body of the story you would include a quote from police explicitly supporting that claim in the lede).
Now, was it fair to call the intersection unsafe? This was a bit dicier. The information you were given said there were no warning lights or a crossing gate, but there were warning signs and a stop sign.
So, is that necessarily unsafe? If later in your story you cited some sort of expert or experts (like cops or safety engineers) or other people in the know (frequent users of the intersection), saying it's unsafe and offering a justification of why it's unsafe, then I'd say you're in the right.
But while this is clearly a less-protected crossing, I think it's a leap to say it's unsafe, in lieu of additional information.
Tuesday, May 22, 2012
More Ledes: What Crashed? What Died? How much?
Ledes are hard in that you need to include all the info critical to
understand the basic gist of the story, but at the same time you need to
keep it brief and exclude any secondary details that may be helpful but
not critical. That's a lot to take into consideration.
In that process, you may end up leaving out something so obvious, it's easy to forget it. Like in this lede:
A local groom fatally crashed while speeding towards church to get married early this morning, according to a police report.
He must have been a fast runner.
I say that because you didn't say he crashed while driving his car. All you say is that he crashed, nothing else included. Coulda been riding a bike or a train or a plane, or nothing at all.
In another lede, you said a 22-year-old was killed. A 22-year-old what? Man? Car? Dog? Again, be precise.
Don't assume the reader knows a car was involved, and a man was killed. Don't make the reader guess that. Be clear AND concise. Not one or the other.
Also, look for details that are easy to understand, and try to add those where you can. In many of your jail ledes you referred to a new fee. But part of context in the story is how much the fee is. After all, a $2 fee isn't much of a story, but a $2,000 fee is.
And it would have been so easy to add the amount by calling the new fee a new $25 fee. Not exactly adding much wordiness there. But it adds so much context and meaning.
In that process, you may end up leaving out something so obvious, it's easy to forget it. Like in this lede:
A local groom fatally crashed while speeding towards church to get married early this morning, according to a police report.
He must have been a fast runner.
I say that because you didn't say he crashed while driving his car. All you say is that he crashed, nothing else included. Coulda been riding a bike or a train or a plane, or nothing at all.
In another lede, you said a 22-year-old was killed. A 22-year-old what? Man? Car? Dog? Again, be precise.
Don't assume the reader knows a car was involved, and a man was killed. Don't make the reader guess that. Be clear AND concise. Not one or the other.
Also, look for details that are easy to understand, and try to add those where you can. In many of your jail ledes you referred to a new fee. But part of context in the story is how much the fee is. After all, a $2 fee isn't much of a story, but a $2,000 fee is.
And it would have been so easy to add the amount by calling the new fee a new $25 fee. Not exactly adding much wordiness there. But it adds so much context and meaning.
Ledes: Seek Missing Information
There was a sort of trick question in this exercise, and that would be on the one citing Mayor Datolli.
In journalism, we fully identify people in first referring to them in a story. So in a first reference, it's Omar Sofradzija, with both the first and last name.
In subsequent references, however, you just use the last name: just Sofradzija said, for example.
In this case, though, you weren't given a first name for Datolli. What to do?
As journalists, our job isn't to simply write what is put before us. It's also to seek answers to holes in the information we have.
The correct response would have been to ask me for the mayor's first name. In a real world setting, it would be to find out what the mayor's first name was by making phone calls or checking records or just asking the mayor what the hell her first name was.
Be curious. Don't settle for what you have if what you have leaves unanswered questions.
In journalism, we fully identify people in first referring to them in a story. So in a first reference, it's Omar Sofradzija, with both the first and last name.
In subsequent references, however, you just use the last name: just Sofradzija said, for example.
In this case, though, you weren't given a first name for Datolli. What to do?
As journalists, our job isn't to simply write what is put before us. It's also to seek answers to holes in the information we have.
The correct response would have been to ask me for the mayor's first name. In a real world setting, it would be to find out what the mayor's first name was by making phone calls or checking records or just asking the mayor what the hell her first name was.
Be curious. Don't settle for what you have if what you have leaves unanswered questions.
Tuesday, September 28, 2010
Is this an assumption . . .
. . . or an obvious truth?
We all know that 16-year-old male drivers can be risky business. However, 16-year-old female drivers are becoming just as dangerous . . .
What about here?
The results of a startling psychologists' study today shows . . .
(And if that's fair word use, what is startling? The study or the results?)
We all know that 16-year-old male drivers can be risky business. However, 16-year-old female drivers are becoming just as dangerous . . .
What about here?
The results of a startling psychologists' study today shows . . .
(And if that's fair word use, what is startling? The study or the results?)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)