Monday, October 18, 2010
Speech -- Writing With (AP) Style
It's the latter. Under "Detroit":
The city in Michigan stands alone in datelines.
And under "cities and towns":
See datelines for guidelines on when they should be followed by a state or country name.
There ya go.
BTW, how many of you are unclear on what is a dateline?
Speech -- Better Word Order . . .
In a speech made Sunday night made by the surgeon general, alcohol has been recognized as the nation's number one drug problem among youth, and the alcohol industry is taking advantage.
. . . to this . . .
In a speech Sunday night, the surgeon general recognized alcohol as the nation's number one drug problem among youth, and the alcohol industry is taking advantage.
In "made by the surgeon general, alcohol has been recognized," I dropped the empty "made" and then rearranged "surgeon general," "alcohol" and "recognized" while cutting the then-unnecessary "made by" and "has been."
See how this streamlines things?
Here's a simpler example:
. . . according to the Surgeon General of the U.S. Public Health Service, Tom Izzo.
Why not just reorder it to say:
. . . according to U.S. Public Health Service Surgeon General Tom Izzo.
. . . and drop the "of the"?
Speech -- How Did You Know . . .
According to the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, 4.6 million teenagers have a drinking problem.
This is kind of a trick question. You DON'T know this because the NIAAA told you, or because you read their report. You know it because Izzo cited the report, right?
So, correct attribution would be something like this:
Izzo said 4.6 million teenagers have a drinking problem, citing National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism figures.
Speech -- Good Quote!
"Let us not make this year, the year they robbed the kids of Halloween," Izzo said. "For their sake and our own, let us keep Halloween sane, safe -- and sober."
Telling quote. It really got to the point of what many of you hooked your stories upon.
Then why did so many of you use it late in your stories?
The better a quote and the more it directly supports your central premise of key premises of your story, the more prominent and higher up that quote should be.
Speech -- Is This Fair?
Izzo's anger and frustrations with the alcohol industry was apparent throughout his speech.
It was closely followed with these quotes:
"The availability of alcohol and its acceptance, even glamorization, in our society are factors," he said. "Trick or treat. This year the alcohol industry has given new meaning to those innocent words of childhood."
"They (the alcohol industry) are serving up now treats -- and new tricks."
"The alcohol industry and its hired guns, the advertising agencies, know these facts," he said. (They have) chosen to be part of the problem, it is up to you to be part of the solution."
What do you think?
Friday, October 15, 2010
Out Of Class Story #1 -- Bad Newz
I'm sorry to say TWO people fataled the first out of class story. One was a time fatal -- it was not turned in before or during the last class. And in the other, the person had two misspellings within a quote that changed the meaning of the words.
And yes, these were words that, when misspelled, created different but correctly-spelled words: sad became said, and lose became loose.
The only good news is that a fatal on this out of class story is salvageable. Fix the fatals -- in the case of the time fatal, that means simply turning in the work by the next due date; and in the case of the spelling fatals, that means simply correcting the spellings -- and the fatal will become only one-third of your assignment grade, with your rewrite grade being two-thirds.
Yes, getting a zero on one-third of your grade will mean you'll probably have a lower overall grade than you'd like, but a zero on one-third of your grade is still a helluva lot better than a zero on three-third of your grade.
Two more things to remember here: One, DO NOT INSERT A FATAL IN YOUR REWRITE THAT WAS NOT IN YOUR ORIGINAL STORY. For these two folks, that would be a killer. Make sure what you have is fact-checked!
Second, you will NOT have rewrite opportunities on the third and fourth out of class stories. Any fatal in those stories won't be fixable.
So let's be careful out there, okay?
Out Of Class Story #1 -- Neutral Experts
One thing I will get into in a bit of detail is the concept of neutral experts.
Neutral experts are people who have a great deal of knowledge and/or expertise regarding the subject you're wring about, but importantly they don't have an interest in the outcome. It's someone who can offer analysis that helps readers decide which side of an issue is more credible. In a one-sided story, it helps readers evaluate whether the people you're writing about are on the up and up.
Think of it in terms of a game: you normally have one side and the other side, right? How you view the game depends on which side you're on. Unless you have a referee, that is. A neutral expert is sort of a referee, helping point on when one side is telling the truth and the other side is stretching it a bit -- or a lot.
Most news stories at least attempt to include at least one neutral expert. And almost all of your stories would have benefited from having a neutral expert included.
One person actually did find a neutral expert for their report. The story was about a Pennsylvania college which blocked students and faculty from using Facebook for a week, as part of a social science experiment.
The story cited officials from the school, of course. But the story also sought comment from an MSU prof who researches social media in general but who has nothing to do with the Pennsylvania project. That prof could expertly evaluate the experiment without any obvious bias like an official at the Pennsylvania school could be perceived as having (after all, that official wouldn't want his school to look bad, right?).
You can find a neutral expert about almost anything, no matter how obscure. Let's look at this example: during the run-up to the 2008 presidential election, a lot was made about how the Obamas would fist-bump each other. The New York Times Sunday Magazine even did a story about it.
Here's how the story started:
Is this the end of high-five?
On the night in June that Barack Obama clinched the Democratic nomination, he and his wife, Michelle, exchanged what was variously described as a “closed-fist high five,” a “fist pound,” a “knuckle buckle” and a “fist jab.” Jonathan Tilove in The New Orleans Times-Picayune called the gesture “the dap heard ’round the world,” which he felt encapsulated “the new cultural trajectory of American politics.”
Believe it or not, they found an expert on fist-bumping. And that expert is right here. Let's continue the story:
Prof. Geneva Smitherman, director of African-American language study at Michigan State University, says: “Pound is when knuckles touch in a horizontal position. That’s the gesture that Michelle and Barack used. Dap is when the knuckles touch in a vertical position. Both gestures can be used as a greeting, to signal respect, agreement, bonding.”
Dap started among black soldiers during the Vietnam War; to give “some dap” (not usually “a” dap) means “to offer kudos, congratulations”; Prof. James Peterson of Bucknell, a hip-hop historian, says he thinks it is rooted in dapper, “neat, fashionably smart.” Pound came out of hip-hop in the late 1980s. Fist bump came later: a 1996 note in the Sports Network wire service reported that Eddie Murray of the Baltimore Orioles was accepting congratulations from baseball teammates with “high-fives, handshakes or fist bumps.” Peterson says the new phrase robs the gesture of its cultural significance, which includes the Obamas’ “quiet but pronounced in-group affiliation with all of black America.”
Hand signals have a checkered history in politics, from Prime Minister Winston Churchill’s V-for-victory sign to the famed photo of Gov. Nelson Rockefeller “giving the finger” to hecklers to the clenched-fist salute of “black power” to Lyndon Johnson’s fondness for “pressing the flesh.”
When Michelle Obama visited Barbara Walters on “The View” on ABC, the candidate’s wife sought to soften her image with “I have to be greeted properly. Fist bump, please. It is now my signature bump. . . . I got it from the young staff. That’s the new high-five.”
Colleges are notorious for being loaded with neutral experts (think of all your profs doing research, and all the TA's working on their thesis papers!) So really, there's no excuse for you NOT to find a neutral expert, especially here or at other schools.Like many other schools, MSU -- in hopes of getting free publicity -- even makes it easy to find experts. The MSU News Office's Web site has an experts list, which you can link to here: http://news.msu.edu/experts/Results/?
Just looking at the first page, these are just some of the topics for which MSU can find you a neutral expert: wind power, renewable energy, water preservation, breast cancer, breast cancer education, medical education, microfinance, filmmaking, documentary production, sensors and nano-bisensor devices for biodefense, health diagnostics and theraputics, child welfare, biblical references and history, Samartian population, meteorology and climatology, Isreali-Palestinian conflict, Israeli politics, society and culture, international relations, U.S. foreign policy, school funding, school choice, school district building projects, the effects of mass communications, health communications, communications campaigns, international relations, the Middle East, Muslim issues, the early formation of galaxies, tax and expenditure policies, state and local public finance, poverty and income distribution, campus sustainability, Internet governance, new wireless technologies, telecommunications regulation and policy, bone and tissue engineering, labor markets, chaos theory, alternative dispute resolution, primitive stars, galaxy formation, labor unions and collective bargaining, international and domestic labor policy, work and family policy, flexible scheduling policy, tropical diseases, malaria, AIDS/HIV . . .
. . . and those are just a FEW of the subject areas!
You can also search by typing in a topic here: http://news.msu.edu/experts/
I took some of your general topics and looked for experts. Like Google, sometimes you have to try the same general term in different ways (like if you're searching for an expert in campus safety, you try that term, then campus, then safety, then police, and so on).
Under "campus living" I found one expert. For "transportation" I found two. There were three each for "housing" and "discrimination" and "elections." I found four each for "police" and "campus" and "drug." For "safety" I found 14! And "health" produced 35!
And you can filter by these general topic areas: agruculture and environment; arts and humanities; athletics; board and administration; business, economy, law and communications; education; family and social issues; health, medicine and veterinary medicine; international; science and technology; staff and faculty; students and campus life; tuition, costs and enrollment.
Plus, there's always Google, right? And other schools as well. And think tanks. And private research institutions.
Wherever you find a good one, it's critical that you do. Journalism isn't about just getting both sides of the story. Getting one side and the other side and nothing else is just enabling a fight.
We're about trying to arrive at a verifiable version of the truth based on facts and checking out what people have to say, right? That's the role a neutral expert helps accomplish.
To paraphrase legendary baseball announcer and willful drunk Harry Caray -- and this might be the only smart thing he ever said in his life, God rest his soul -- there are three sides to every story: your side, my side, and the truth.
We need to get more than two out of three. We need all of 'em.
Go find some neutral experts!
Thursday, October 14, 2010
Murder -- Too Many Fatals
But my feelings don't matter here; learning from these mistakes is Let's go over what went wrong:
>>> You offered the wrong time element.
One story reported the robbery took place last night. Another reported it was this morning. In fact, it was yesterday morning.
>>> You misspelled the name of a central fact: the location.
You spelled North Pointe Inn, when in fact it was North Point Inn.
I've been giving some latitude to misspellings, as long as those misspelling do not involve changing a quote or one of the five W's in a story. This one regarded where, a central fact.
>>> You incorrectly quoted your sources.
One person quoted Cortez as saying "but I locked it." In fact, she said "but I'd locked it."
Another person quoted Cortez as saying Blohm has "another in his had," when in fact she said "another on one hand."
And Cortez was also quoted as saying she heard someone say, "Get the money out of here," when in fact the person said "Get that money out of here."
Additionally, some of you almost fataled by firmly asserting there WERE two suspects. You don't know that for sure; you have reason to believe there MAY have been a second suspect, but your witness could only absolutely confirm one.
We say NOT to assume, right? Well, don't. You can say there was at least one suspect or that there may have been a second suspect, but to go beyond that -- that is, what you know for sure -- is to assume.
Maybe if I were in a worse mood I would have put those down as fatals. Please, folks, don't have your grade rest on whether I'm feeling generous or not. Instead, guarantee an acceptable grade by committing to the fundamentals of vetting your work.
Check EVERY spelling, EVERY line, EVERY date, EVERY statistic, EVERY quote and EVERY fact for accuracy once you finish writing your story, and before you turn in your report.
Please, folks. You're better than this.
Murder -- Nuts!
What a nut graf offered in those situations is more detail to support your lede. And that in and of itself allowed for a less jarring transition from a brief and general lede to a timeline telling.
Here's a good sequence of lede-nut graf-chronology:
A robbery at the North Point Inn restaurant in Okemos yesterday resulted in the death of one employee while another employee managed to stay safe by locking herself in her office.
Cook Kevin Blohm was found dead with large knife wounds in his chest and hand after police came to the scene, according to bookkeeper Nina Cortez.
Cortez said the robbery too place shortly after 9 a.m., when she arrived at the restaurant to start counting revenue from the previous day.
Imagine if the nut graf was missing here. You start hearing Taylor's story before you have enough of a summation to know what she is going to detail.
Nut grafs allow you to offer that extra level of detail that essentially forms a mini-story atop the body of a story. In the same way a lede gives you the bare minimum you need to know about a story, the nut graf gives readers the bare minimum of background and details to make broader sense of the lede.
Again, you need to forget about classic English composition where the ending is at the end of the story. Here, the ending is at the start. Be sure to have a complete enough ending before people get into the meat of the story.
Here's another good lede-nut-chronology sequence:
A local restaurant cook was stabbed t death yesterday morning when an unidentified male and a possible accomplice robbed the North Point Inn in Okemos, according to the restaurant's bookkeeper.
Kevin Blohm, one of the cooks at the restaurant, was found dead on the floor in the reception area of the restaurant by the Okemos Police Department and and the restaurant's bookkeeper, Nina Cortez. Blohm had a large knife wound in his chest and another on his hand.
At approximately 9 a.m. Cortez was sitting in her office going through receipts and cash from the previous evening when a man walked around the corner holding a knife, she said.
Murder -- Say Something!
Cortez, a bookkeeper at the Okemos inn for seven years, recalls her last interaction with her victim, Kevin Blohm.
The graf tells me the key point here is that she spoke. But that's not the news; the news is what she said, right?
Think back to the football story situation we often talked about at the start of this semester. The news from a football game isn't that a game was played; it's what happened at the game; who won or lost, and why.
So instead of saying he recalled the last interaction, I'd write what she said that last interaction was; e.g., Cortez said she and Blohm talked about what happened at the restaurant the previous night before she asked him to make her some coffee.
See the difference? You tell your readers something now.
Murder -- Too Flippant . . .
Forget million-dollar bank heists as seen in movies. One man was killed in Okemos yesterday by a robber who escaped with $130 from the North Point Inn.
What do you think?
Murder -- Sufficient Description
. . . "He was about 5 feet 10 inches, maybe 6 feet tall, in his early 20s, medium build."
Is that sufficient? No. It's too vague to be very useful to readers.
Think about it. How many people in the world fit that description? It's so many that you are not narrowing down suspect possibilities in the mind of the public; you actually are making a whole lot of innocent people look guilty!
It's best to use suspect descriptions when you are so specific that it can narrow down the suspect pool, like here:
The robber was between 5 foot 10 inches and 6 feet tall, in his early 20s, medium build, wearing a floral scarf over his face, blue jeans, a blue plaid button-up shirt and blue tennis shoes, and may have had an accomplice, according to Cortez.
This ID is far more useful. Besides telling readers the killer is color-blind, it's a distinctive description that -- combined with the time and place -- helps readers zero in on a single suspect, or a limited suspect pool.
Murder -- Did You Need Quotes . . .
The man can be described as "5'10", maybe 6'0" tall, early 20s, medium build," according to Cortez.
There really isn't any difference between quoting this or paraphrasing this. As a quote, it really doesn't add a more human tone or voice than it would as a paraphrase.
If a quote is dull, technical or lacks a human-sounding voice, you're probably better off just paraphrasing the person.
Murder -- Spell Check Didn't Help . . .
. . . or whether he just got in THERE way.
. . . or this . . .
. . . he had a scarf on the LOVER part, cowboy style.
(Uh, I'm pretty sure that gets an "R" movie rating right there)
Again, be sure you're actually reading your finished work, and not just taking spell check's word for it.
Murder -- Write With (AP) Style
It's the first on or the last one. AP Style, under "dimensions":
Use figures and spell out inches, feet, yards, ect, to indicate depth, height, length and width. Hyphenate adjectival forms before nouns.
EXAMPLES: He is 5 feet 6 inches tall, the 5-foot-6-inch man, the 5-foot man, the basketball team signed a 7-footer.
Use an apostrophe to indicate feet and quote marks to indicate inches (5'6") only in very technical contexts.
Moving on, in referring to the day of the week, should you have said yesterday or Tuesday (or Wednesday, depending on which day you filed your assignment)?
In general, it's the latter. Sayeth AP Style under "time element":
Use the days of the week, not today or tonight in print copy. Use the month and a figure where appropriate.
Wednesday, October 13, 2010
Bicyclists -- Ledes
A lede that passes the peanut Barrel test. A lede that makes things clear for readers and intrugues them, pulling them into the greater story. A lede that sums up what is the latest and most important. A lede that looks at ultimate outcome and context.
This lede accomplished many of those basic and important goals:
Holt resident Marsha Taylor was in the hospital for four months after a bicycling accident that could have paralyzed her. She was released two days ago.
Still, that lede leaves something to be desired. Yes, the accident was the most serious consequence here. But four months ago as a long time ago. That has to be very old news.
Given the disparity in time, I think it would have been wise to emphasize the timelier event, which of course was still directly connected to the accident since it was the reason she was in the hospital in the first place. This lede did that:
A local bicyclist was released from Mueller Memorial Hospital two days ago after spending four months there while recovering from injuries after being hit by a car while biking in Holt.
That's a good lede. But I found a better lede, one that highlighted something that made this story a bit more interesting: the fact that wrecking her body hasn't scared her off from riding.
A bike-riding accident that would have kept most cyclists off their bikes for good is not stopping Holt resident Marsha Taylor from getting back on the horse.
I'm not sure I would have used a cliche like "on the horse," but it certainly hits a Peanut Barrel point. To-wit:
"Hey Omar, what story did you work on today?"
"I wrote about this woman who just got outta the hospital after getting all busted up riding her bike. And even though she got all messed up, she still wants to ride!"
That's one thing that makes this story a little bit different from any other accident story, right?
This lede disregarded the time element by putting the latest happening in a delayed lede role, and turned the accident into a mini-anecdote, like this:
Approximately two week after biking across the U.S. with no complications, 37-year-old Marsha Taylor arrived back in Holt only to become the victim of a severe biking accident.
She was released just two days ago after spending four months recovering in Mueller Memorial Hospital.
The opening of this lede obviously isn't pegged to the time element, like the first lede we looked at. It essentially turns the lede into a mini-anecdote that's a bit more personalized.
But it differs from the first lede in a very significant regard: it is trying to set context and tell a bigger story that goes straight to the Peanut Barrel rule: that somebody rode a bike across the country without a scratch, and then broke her body right by her home.
You know, it considers an angle that makes this story unique. It's ironic. It's contextual. It's a good lede, and great vision in terms of identifying what made a story truly different from the usual and expected.
Bicyclists -- Quotes
For those of you who hooked the story on the angle that Taylor can't wait to write again, you had a golden quote to use:
"I still want to ride. If I could, I'd be out there right now, but it's hard to ride a bike when you have to use crutches," Taylor said.
Great quote, right? Looking at the get-back-on-that-horse lede, it would be a perfect quote to support and confirm the lede for readers, right? Sums up your main point nicely, does it not?
Then why do I find it in the 13th graf of that story?
That's not the worst of it. Another one of you who had a similar lede saved that quote for the last graf of their story.
I think it would have been better positioned as the first quote you use in the story, ideally after the lede and nut graf and before you moved into the body of the story with a chronological telling.
It's not enough to find quotes that support central points of your story. It's not even enough to use quotes that support central points of your story. You should make sure the best quotes that best support your central points are ranked within your story in a spot that recognizes the prominence.
In the same way that it's not enough to have a story that's relevant, interesting and useful and that you need to have a lede where the relevance, interest and utility shine through; it's not enough to have a story with good quotes and you need to have a story where good quotes shine through.
Bicyclists -- Nuts!
Many of you were missing nut grafs, leaving a hole between the lede summarizing the story, and the body of the story offering a chronological telling of how events unfolded.
What a nut graf would have offered in those situations is more detail to support your lede. And that in and of itself would have allowed for a less jarring transition from a brief and general lede to a timeline telling.
Here's a good sequence of lede-nut graf-chronology:
A local bicycist was released from Mueller Memorial Hospital two days ago after spending four months there while recovering from injuries after being hit by a car while biking in Holt.
Marsha Taylor, a 37-year-old Harvard University graduate and McDonald's employee of 15 years, said the accident happened soon after she finished the U.S. tour. She had been back in Holt for about two weeks when the accident occurred.
"I was riding down 72nd Street almost to Southland Boulevard when a car hit me from behind and sent me flying off my bike," Taylor said.
Imagine if the nut graf was missing here. You start hearing Taylor's story before you have enough of a summation to know what she is going to detail.
Nut grafs allow you to offer that extra level of detail that essentially forms a mini-story atop the body of a story. In the same way a lede gives you the bare minimum you need to know about a story, the nut graf gives readers the bare minimum of background and details to make broader sense of the lede.
Again, you need to forget about classic English composition where the ending is at the end of the story. Here, the ending is at the start. Be sure to have a complete enough ending before people get into the meat of the story.
Bicyclist -- Did You . . .
One person put her job status in their lede. Was that necessary?
Bicyclist -- Punctuation Points
Most of the time, an attributing "he said" or "she said" should end with a period. Like this:
"One doctor said I had what they called a hangman's facture," Taylor said. "She said it was a miracle that I wasn't paralyzed."
Also, punctuation marks should go INSIDE of quotes, like this:
. . . you have to use crutches," Taylor said.
And not OUTSIDE of quotes, like this:
. . . you have to use crutches", Taylor said.