Thursday, September 22, 2011
Ledes: Understand What You Are Writing!
A senior citizen was arrested and charged with grand theft and adoption fraud after faking a pregnancy for the purpose of receiving benefits from the Hope Agency.
Uh, where did you get that the person was a senior citizen? I don't see that in the information you were provided. Additionally, if you did think that, wouldn't you question it because senior citizens can't get pregnant?
I suspect you may have mistaken the woman's apartment number -- 74 -- with her age. Make sure you understand what you are writing before you start writing.
I can't decide if that should get the award for the biggest goof of the day. This next lede is certainly a contender:
A woman was arrested today for grand theft and defrauding an abortion agency by faking her pregnancy.
Oy, vey. I know you meant adoption. But that's not what you wrote. Please, proof-read your work because spell check won't catch you using the wrong word, as long as the wrong word is spelled correctly.
There were two such cases of that. In another instance, someone wrote "lighting" when they meant to write "lightning." Again, spell check is a supplement to but not a substitute for reviewing the story yourself, line by line.
If this happened to be a normally-graded exercise, all three of these examples would have qualified as fatals and an automatic grade of 1.0 out of 4.0. So let's be careful out there.
In the same vein, make sure what you write can be understood clearly by others. This one leaves a bit of room for interpretation:
After receiving $12,000 to pay for medical expenses and signing adoption papers for a made-up pregnancy, police arrested Cynthia Lowrie for grand theft and defrauding of the agency.
Readers can probably figure this out on their own, but let's look at what you wrote in a literal way: did Cythnia do all that before she was arrested? Or did the police do all that before arresting Cynthia? You would have been better off to eliminate any chance of misunderstanding like this:
After Cynthia Lowrie received $12,000 to pay for medical expenses and signed adoption papers for a made-up pregnancy, police arrested her for grand theft and defrauding of the agency.
(There's something else to consider here: in your lede, you shifted between tenses. At one point you were going with -ing, and at another you shifted to -ed. Try to maintain the same tense throughout.)
This next lede also leaves some room for confusion:
Mayor Datolli announced today that she will introduce a new ordinance to the city council to decrease the amount of panhandling at their annual Tuesday meeting.
Again, let's read this literally. You are saying that they are trying to decrease the panhandling that happens at their meetings. Obviously not what you meant to say. Better word order would have helped make that point clear, like this:
Mayor Datolli announced today that she will introduce a new ordinance to the city council at their annual Tuesday meeting to decrease the amount of panhandling.
Neither lede is the most confusing lede ever. Not even close. Still, our job as journalists is to be precise. Leave no room for mistaken interpretation.
FYI, technically there's a fatal there, too: you had no information that meetings were annual, which by definition means once a year. Again, be careful with word use.
Finally, make sure you identify the latest highlight and outcome in your lede. This one did not do that:
Erik Barsh suffered brain and nerve injuries and the loss of a friend after they were hit by lightning at a swimming pool when lifeguards failed to evaluate swimmers.
The latest event wasn't that they were hit by lightning. That happened a year ago. The reason it's news now is because Barsh is now suing. This lede may have worked if it was a delayed lede, followed by this:
Now, Barsh wants the city to pay for that.
Or something like that. Either way, just be sure that what you're pegging your story on is what makes it news. And what usually makes it news is whatever is new.
Ledes: Writing With (AP) Style
Like with how to refer to money. Is it $12,000 with the dollar symbol ahead of the amount or 12,000 dollars, with dollars spelled out?
It's the former This is what I pulled from the AP Stylebook, under dollars: "Use figures and the $ sign in all except casual references or amounts without a figure."
Number usage has its own specific style under AP rules. Here's the most basic AP guideline, in your style book under numerals: In general "Spell out whole numbers below 10, use figures for 10 and above."
So two should be two, not 2. And 10 should be 10, not ten.
So then, is this correct to start a sentence, under AP Style rules, by spelling out a number like this?
Twenty-two . . .
Actually, that IS correct number use. This is under the numerals heading:
Spell out a numeral at the beginning of a sentence.
Also, Is it 17 year-old with a hyphen between year and old or 17-year-old with hyphens between everything or 17 year old with no hyphens at all? AP Style under "ages": Use hyphens for ages expressed as adjectives before a noun or as substitutes for a noun.
So it's 17-year-old, with hyphens between the 17 and year, and between the year and old.
Another AP no-no is using the percentage symbol of % instead of spelling out the word percent. The correct use is to spell out the symbol, like this: 35 percent. Please review the AP listing under percent.
Moving on, many of you referred to the Centers for Disease Control as just that in your lede. A few of you called used its acronym of CDC in a first reference. An acronym is a word formed from the first letter or letters of a series of words, such as MSU (which is the acronym for Michigan State University).
And using an acronym on first reference is probably a no-no.
In most first cases, it's best to spell out the full title of an entity. If an acronym is especially well-known -- like NASA or FBI or USA -- then generally it is acceptable in a first reference. I'm not sure CDC makes that cut, FYI.
Now, in subsequent references you have a few options. One is to refer to the center in the generic, like I just did: as the center, lower-cased. A second option would be to consider using the acronym, after establishing what the acronym is in the first reference.
This is where I'm going to refer you back to AP Style. Please carefully read and review the listing for abbreviations and acronyms.
Speaking of the CDC, was it Center for Disease Control or Centers for Disease Control? Did anybody check AP style under Centers for Disease Control? What does it say?
The idea behind AP style is not simply to drive you crazy; it's also to create a consistent way of referring to terms and phrases and stats and such throughout not just a story, but throughout all stories offered by a single media organization. Consistency is the key point I'd like you to learn here, and we'll use AP style as the baseline.
I know the AP Stylebook is a lot to digest. But as this class goes on, I expect that you improve by checking your word use against the AP Stylebook, and by remembering AP Style rules as we go along.
What I'm saying is, I don't expect you to make the same mistake twice. I expect you to learn from your mistakes and apply the lessons going forward.
When it comes to types of language you're likely to frequently -- like numbers and money references -- you may want to make a cheat sheet that you can quickly refer to. Just an idea, folks.
Thursday, June 23, 2011
Test Story #3 -- Fatals Changes
Wednesday, June 22, 2011
Test Story #3 -- An Overview
The news isn't that things were discussed; it's what was done or not done. Too many ledes or section starts defaulted to things were discussed. That's not the news, right?
This was a lede that went in that direction:
Label transitions to subsections. When ending reporting on one item and beginning another item, use transitional tags at the start of a subsection lede like, "In other business," or "Also at the meeting," so readers can see the transition point clearly.
Fact-checking includes checking for AP Style. I don't still have to remind you of that, do I?
BTW, the last class I taught had the best overall grades of any class I taught. So if this class follows suit, this exercise can be put under the category of lessons successfully learned.
Ethics -- What Would You Do?
I can think of no better example of this than the so-called Falling man photo, taken by an Associated Press photographer during the Sept. 11, 2001 terror attacks and published by The New York Times the next day.
This remarkable article from Esquire Magazine in 2003 offers a summation of the complex and contradictory forces at play in deciding if running the image was the absolute right thing or the incredibly wrong thing to do.
If you were an editor on Sept. 11, what would you have done? And why?
Monday, June 20, 2011
Video #2 -- Let's Look At Some Vids ...
Flight -- Peanut Barrel Rule
Flight -- Missing Nut Grafs
A 12-year-old girl landed a 4-passenger plane after her father slumped over in his seat while flying it today.
James Shanahan, a licensed pilot, his two daughters, Alyssa and Adrienne and his wife, Mary, were flying from Grand Rapids, Mich., when he suffered an allergic reaction from prescription medication he began taking this morning.
A small aircraft made a dramatic emergency landing at City Regional Airport this afternoon, the family inside escaping with minimal injuries, police and emergency officials say.
Authorities say 12-year-old Alyssa Shanahan took over the flight controls after her father went unconscious due to an allergic reaction to his medication, maneuvering an emergency landing on a field near the airport’s runway — avoiding any severe injuries for her family members in the plane.
Here's another way to judge nut graf adequacy: if you removed the lede and nut graf from the rest of the story and just showed readers those first two grafs, could they be able to accurately summarize the story?
Flight -- Too Many Fatals
Flight -- Some Little Stuff
Wednesday, June 15, 2011
Video/Blogs/Tweets -- More Intros
JRN 200 -- Sneakers Be Sneakin'
That's because people went into their blogs after seeing the critique, and made the necessary changes.
Still, please pay attention to the point being noted.
Tuesday, June 14, 2011
Meeting -- Fatals Watch
Meeting -- Write With (AP) Style
Stats -- Get To The Point
Conducted in October for the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the survey came from a series of questionnaire supplements conducted as part of the Current Population Survey (CPS). The CPS is a survey of about 50,000 households, is conducted each month by the U.S. Census Bureau, and has come to be used as a tool to measure many economic, demographic, and social conditions of the U.S. population.
Statistics from the survey include the age, sex, race, and education of the householder; the type, size, income, and number of children in the household; and the household’s region.
In 1984, 8.2 percent of U.S. households reported to the Census Bureau that they owned a home computer. By 1997, it increased to 36.6 percent. Currently, 61.8 percent of 113.1 million American households have one or more computers, shows the survey’s findings.
A recent U.S. Census Bureau survey on American computer and internet use shows ownership and usage in households has dramatically increased since the early 1980s.
In 1984, 8.2 percent of U.S. households reported to the Census Bureau that they owned a home computer. By 1997, it increased to 36.6 percent. Currently, 61.8 percent of 113.1 million American households have one or more computers, shows the survey’s findings.
Stats -- Watch Your Math
Stats -- Write With (AP) Style
Monday, June 13, 2011
Twitter -- Let's Look At Some Tweets!
The problem, if there was one, was with the hash tag. Hash tags gather tweets with that tag not only from you, but from anybody in the world that uses the same hash tag. Because your hash tag wasn't unique enough, hash tag users got this.
A similar problem was faced by this tweet stream, also about the NBA, which used another popular hash tag. Same with this one, on the same topic.
Yet another basketball tweet stream did something different here: it used a tweet to ask a reader a question, and to gain a response via tweet. In the same way blogs differ from news stories in using its multi-dimensionality via hyperlinks, tweets allow you to interact with your audience while you report a story, something the print medium simply can't do.
Here's some tweets following a soccer game, and with a more unique hash tag.
Now, let's get away from sports. This one followed a Harry Potter movie. Again, you get a play-by-play. This one followed a TV show episode. Another one followed a baseball game. Tweeting is really that easy.
Here are some more tweet streams: of a city council meeting (FYI -- watch identifications so they are clear to readers). This one is following a TV show episode.