Thursday, September 29, 2011

Graded Ledes: Look For Inclusive Words!

Many of you in the animals lede referred to "ecologists and biologists." A couple of you simply referred to "scientists."

And why not? Ecologists and biologists are scientists. It's simpler and doesn't result in any lost meaning to your readers.

If you have the opportunity to group specifics under a single umbrella term, consider that course of action.

Graded Ledes: Avoid Redundant Words!

Like if you say, "a local East Lansing store." East Lansing is the locality, so you could just say, "East Lansing store" with no "local" and save a word.

Graded Ledes: Watch Wordiness!

Watch for opportunities to take many words and say the same thing with fewer words.

Like with, "preceded to carjack a vehicle." Why not just say "carjacked a vehicle" and save a couple of words?

Graded Ledes: Watch Word Order!

Watch your word order for opportunities to shorten sentences.

For example, why say, "was the victim of a carjacking" when you could say, "was a carjacking victim" and save two words in the process?

Graded Ledes: A Versus The

So is it a six-month-old girl? Or the six-month-old girl?

In first reference, it's a six-month-old. After all, she's not the only six-month-old girl in the world, probably.

But after establishing her as a specific six-month-old girl, for second and subsequent references you could call her the girl.

Graded Ledes: Writing With (AP) Style

In writing about this robbery, one of you referred to the robber as a thief. Are those terms interchangeable? No. How do I know that? AP Style.

This is what it says under burglary, larceny, robbery, theft:

Legal definitions of burglary vary, but in general a burglary involves entering a building (not necessarily by breaking in) and remaining unlawfully with the intention of committing a crime.

Larceny is the legal term for the wrongful taking of property. Its nonlegal equivalents are stealing or theft.

Robbery in the legal sense involves the use of violence or threat in committing larceny. In a wider sense it means to plunder or rifle, and may thus be used even if a person was not present: His house was robbed while he was away.

Theft describes a larceny that did not involve threat, violence or plundering.

So, based on that information, was he a robber or a thief? Why or why not?

Also, was the address 2752 Michigan Ave or 2752 Michigan Ave. or 2752 Michigan Avenue?

From AP Style, under addresses:

Use the abbreviations Ave., Blvd. and St. only with a numbered address: 1600 Pennsylvania Ave. Spell them out and capitalize when part of a formal street name without a number: Pennsylvania Avenue. Lowercase and spell out when used alone or with more than one street name: Massachusetts and Pennsylvania avenues.

Spell out and capitalize First through Ninth when used as street names; use figures with two letters for 10th and above: 7 Fifth Ave., 100 21st St.

So in this case, it's 2752 Michigan Ave.

Tuesday, September 27, 2011

More Ledes: Ledes I Liked

Again, nice work on the latest ledes exercise. You are all picking this up very well. A bunch of good ones, and here's a sampling of a few of 'em:

Fifteen minutes before he was supposed to walk down the aisle today, Scott Forsythe died in a car accident on Kirkmann Road, a half-mile from the church.

In that one,m you let the facts speak for themselves. In the next lede, you set context through the stark contrast between the joy of a wedding and the horror of a death:

Sara Howard though today would the the happiest of her life, when it turned into the worst when her fiance died in a car crash while swerving to avoid a dog.

This next one sets context through a quip and word play:

Being a suspect in a crime will cost you, literally. East Lansing city officials announced today that suspects will now pay a $25 fee for the process of being arrested.

This next lede doesn't just offer the what, but the why as well.

In an effort to trim expenses, East Lansing officials announced that mug shots and fingerprints now cost those being arrested a fee of $25.

On this next one, it's a straight-to-the-point summary:

A 16-year-old student who was previously arrested for robbing a woman at gunpoint is still allowed to play on his school's football team, even while on house arrest.

This next one uses writing style to create a mini-narrative, in the style of fiction-writing but entirely based on facts:

Several months ago, East Lansing police Detective Larry Chavez arrested a 16-year-old boy for armed robbery. Today, the same boy still plays for his high school football team.

This last one is a delayed lede that has fun with the contrast between a couple of typical -- but very different -- items that say a lot:

Football players usually wear wristbands as an accessory, but what about an electronic bracelet?

Of the last three, which one do you like best, and why?

More Ledes: Fatals Suck

Sorry to say we had some fatals. Happy to say they didn't count again. This is the last exercise where fatals won't ruin your day -- again, you get a 10 out of 10 quiz grade in place of a 4.0 scale grade -- so let's please learn from these examples so we don't fatal when it counts.

Let's look at the first fatal lede:

Lansing city officials will now require all arrested citizens to pay a fee of $25 for their mug shots and fingerprints.

It's a nicely-structured lede, except for one thing: the city in question was East Lansing, not Lansing.

Can you find the fatal in the next lede?

Kennedy High School allows a student convicted of an armed robbery to play in football games and engage in other school activities.

The fatal could be that you labeled the student as convicted of armed robbery. We know he was arrested for armed robbery, but there was no information as to whether he was eventually convicted. When you are arrested and charged with something, you are accused of a crime. You aren't convicted until a judge or jury finds you guilty of a crime.

But that's not the fatal. The fatal is saying this is happening to a Kennedy High School kid. In fact, it's a Colonial High School kid.

The information you were given was that the East Lansing detective went to a Kennedy High football game to watch his son play for Kennedy. Kennedy was playing Colonial. And on Colonial's team the cop saw the criminal.

Yes, it's a little bit of a trick question. And that's on purpose. When I tell you guys that you have to understand what you're writing about, I'm not asking you if you know how to read or if you know English. I'm asking you if you understand the sequence of events and how things went down and what role each high school has in this instance.

That's what I mean by understanding what you write before you write it. And that's why before you start typing away, you need to go through your information and make sure you understand it.

Then again, it does also mean knowing the words you use. There's a fatal here:

Sara Howard thought today would be the happiest of her life when it turned into the worst, when her fiancee died in a car crash while swerving to avoid a dog.

This is the as-written version of one of the ledes I liked, which in that earlier version I corrected. Do you see the fatal?

It's with fiancee. A fiancee with two e's is defined as a woman awaiting marriage, while a man is known as a fiance, with just one e. You used two in referring to a guy. That's a fatal.

That's also an AP Style error. Please see AP Style under the heading of fiance, fiancee.

More Ledes: Peanut Barrel Rule

There's nothing wrong with this lede. But it's still missing something. Here it is:

While a stray dog's life was spared, a 22-year-old was killed when he lost control of his car going 100 mph in order to avoid the dog.

Technically, it's correct. But let's think about the Peanut Barrel rule. If you wrote this story for The State News and then headed down to the Peanut Barrel to meet friends for a legal drink or two afterward, and then they asked you what you wrote about today, what would you say? More importantly, what would be first to come out of your mouth?

"Uh, well I wrote something abut a dude who got killed when he swerved his car to miss a doggie in the road."

I don't think so. What I think you'd say would be something like this:

"Dude, this was so effed up I don't believe it! Some guy was driving his car all crazy fast so he could make it to his wedding, but he CRASHED and DIED! On his WEDDING DAY! Soo effed up."

I really do think you'd certainly include the wedding angle. That's what made this crash unique and especially poignant and tragic.

If it's a fact or angle that would pass the Peanut Barrel test, then it's a good fact or angle for a lede. If your proposed lede doesn't pass Peanut Barrel muster, then try again until it does.

Again, I can't say your lede was incorrect. Clearly, it passes factual muster. But is it really complete? No. It misses context, like calling 9/11 just a plane crash.

More Ledes: Say What You Mean, Mean What You Say

There's a problem with this lede:

Just moments before walking down the aisle, 22-year-old Scott Forsythe swerved his Ford Mustang to spare a dog's life, and lost his own.

Now, in many ways it's not a bad lede. It conveys the meaning fairly well. But what is incorrect -- a fatal, really -- is what it says: that Forsythe lost his life just moments before walking down the aisle.

Read that literally: it doesn't say moments before he was to walk down the aisle, it says a dead guy walked down the aisle, all "Weekend At Bernie's" style.

This lede go that point right:

An East Lansing man was killed in a car accident today at 8:45 a.m. while en route to the church where he was to be married 15 minutes later.

Make sure that you say what you mean, and that you mean what you say.

More Ledes: What Crashed?

Ledes are hard in that you need to include all the info critical to understand the basic gist of the story, but at the same time you need to keep it brief and exclude any secondary details that may be helpful but not critical. That's a lot to take into consideration.

In that process, you may end up leaving out something so obvious, it's easy to forget it. Like in this lede:

Scott Forsythe died this morning 15 minutes before his wedding after he crashed into two trees and a fence going 100 mph to avoid hitting a dog.

Okay, so he hit that fence at 100 mph. He must be a fast runner.

I say that because you didn't say what he hit the fence while driving his car. All you say is that he hit the fence, nothing else included.

In another lede, you said a 22-year-old was killed. A 22-year-old what? Man? Car? Dog? Again, be precise.

Don't assume the reader knows a car was involved, and a man was killed. Don't make the reader guess that. Be clear AND concise. Not one or the other.

More Ledes: Clarity Via Word Order

Often, word order can help create clarity by putting information in a sequence that clearly spells out what happened. Conversely, poor word order can leave things a bit jumbled.

In that sense, this lede had a bit of room for improvement:

A 22-year-old died in a car accident this morning on the way to his wedding by veering off the road to avoid hitting a stray dog.

In this case, you could have arranged fact sequence to pair up commonalities, like this:

A 22-year-old on the way to his wedding died in a car accident this morning by veering off the road to avoid hitting a stray dog.

Before, the fact the man died and how and why he died was split in half by the wedding mention. In the reordering, the crash elements are placed together, and now the sentence flows a bit better.

More Ledes: Flipping The Lede

Quite often, we want to emphasize not who is a source of a story, but what the story is; the actual action taking place. In this lede the action is the new charge:

Today East Lansing city officials announced that new arrestees will be charged $25 for mug shots and finger-printing services, in an attempt to trim expenses.

While the action is the new charge, you start the story with attribution; that is, from whom you're getting the information. By simply flipping the sequence of action and attribution you can emphasize the action, like this:

New arrestees will be charged $25 for mug shots and finger-printing services in an attempt to trim expenses, East Lansing city officials announced today.

Notice here I am using the exact same words you used in your lede. All I did was flip the attribution from the front of the lede to the back, and in doing so I moved the reference to today from the start of the attribution to the end.

The difference is that readers don't have to work through, "officials said blah blah" before getting to the gist of the story. Look at where you place attribution in a lede, and consider whether a flipped lede can help emphasize the main point.

More Ledes: Be Simple

Don't forget to translate and simplify technical terms, like in this lede:

From today forward, city officials announced that anyone who is arrested and incarcerated will be charged $25 by the jail, but will be refunded if later acquitted.

Instead of saying incarcerated, why not just say jailed? Same meaning, but a simpler and more commonly-used term.

More Ledes: Did You Need The Name?

In your ledes, some of you referred to the car accident victim specifically -- Scott Forsythe -- while others referred to him in the generic -- 22-year-old local man, or something to that effect.

While neither is wrong, I'd say the latter is the best approach. You have no reason to believe Forsythe is someone that would be known by name to your readers. In such cases, the generic identifier would suffice in a first reference, and you can offer the specific name as a secondary detail later in the story.

Now, if the victim was Oprah Winfrey, the name would be a good bet for the lede, precisely because she is someone many people would instantly recognize by name.

More Ledes: Write With (AP) Style

Is it 9:00 a.m. or 9 a.m. or 9 am or 9 o'clock?

It's 9 a.m., or maybe 9 o'clock. Under times:

Use figures except for noon and midnight. Use a colon to separate hours from minutes: 11 a.m., 1 p.m., 3:30 p.m. . . . The construction 4 o'clock is acceptable, but time listings with a.m. or p.m. are preferred.

In the wake of this exercise, please be sure to review the AP Style listings for times.

Also, is it miles per hour or mph or m.p.h.?

It's mph or miles per hour. In AP Style, under
, mph: Acceptable in all references for miles per hour or miles an hour.

Please note AP Style for
mph.

Thursday, September 22, 2011

Ledes: Ledes I Liked.

I'm happy to say that everybody did no worse than pretty good in this assignment, which in the past has been an ungraded piece of classwork. This year I'm going to give you some credit, though: you all get a boost to your overall quiz grade that's equivalent to 10 out of 10 on a single quiz. Which some of you could really use.

On this first assignment, it was far less important that I grade you and more critical that you get used to writing in a journalistic style and under a newsroom-type deadline before it starts counting for something.

Still, I think you're right where you need to be. Let's look at some of the ledes I thought worked well:

Couples who live together when they are younger are more likely to break up or divorce later in life, according to the Centers for Disease Control.

It identifies the most telling statistic, highlights it and provides a source for it. Nice work. This one collects a variety of factors:

Religion, age and wealth all factor in whether marriages last, according to the Centers for Disease Control.

Next is this:

Mayor Datolli plans to introduce a panhandling ordinance offering a one-way bus ticket out of town to homeless people at Tuesday's city council meeting.

It has who: the mayor who is acting, and homeless people being acted upon. It has what: the city council wanting to boot the homeless out of here. It has when: as soon as Tuesday's city council meeting. It has how: one-way bus tickets for the homeless. Four of six W's are covered here, and in only 25 words.

Next is this:

A victim of a lightning strike at a city swimming pool is suing the city for his injuries, citing neglect by the lifeguards to warn him of the storm.

Again, it sums everything you need to know in a simple, straightforward way. This next lede went a step further, and honed in on context:

Erik Barsh was going to be a senior tennis star until last summer when he was struck by lightning. Now he is in a legal volley with the city.

This is a more complex type of lede known by various terms, including a delayed lede (where the lede sets up a following nut graf that reads more like a basic lede) and an anecdotal lede (where in this case you are humanizing the subject a bit before plunging into the reason why this particular human is worthy of news coverage).

I didn't plan for you guys doing anything beyond a basic lede for this exercise, but it's fine that you did. We'll talk about alternate ledes and as the term goes on I'll encourage you to try more complex forms of story-telling. But if you want to fall back on the basic lee structure for now, that's perfectly fine. What I want to see you demonstrate for now is proper identification and fact selection. And a basic lede does that just fine.

Cynthia Lowe was arrested today for grand theft and defrauding an adoption agency after faking a pregnancy to receive money.

Very clear and concise. You know who did it, you know what they're charged with, and you know why they've been charged.

Another way to handle it would be to use a generic description of the woman instead of her full name in the lede, since she isn't anybody in particular that readers can expect to know by name, like Britney Spears or something. This lede took the generic approach:

A woman was arrested and charged with grand theft and fraud after faking a pregnancy to receive payments from an adoption agency.

Both these fraud ledes would have been further aided by the introduction of a telling fact that would take little space but say a lot: the exact dollar amount. Take out money and payments and instead put in $20,000. Doesn't that add so much more to the lede, in the same way saying whether a plane crash killed 2 people or 200 would say so much?

Look for those telling specifics that amplify the lede, and use them!

Now, there are some things missing from these and other ledes, like proper use of the word allegedly, and proper attribution use and style. But since we haven't learned those things yet, you weren't docked. And we'll get to learning those things very soon.

Ledes: Don't Forget Your Articles!

I don't mean stories. A mean a grammatical article, like a, an, the.

Like here: Woman arrested today for defrauding adoption agency.

It should be, A woman was arrested today for defrauding an adoption agency.

When it comes to writing for news, what messes us up regarding articles are newspaper headlines, which usually drop articles in favor of brevity. While that is true of headlines, that is not true of the actual stories under the headlines. Articles need articles.

If you're not sure if you have articles, read your story out loud and ask yourself if it sounds like you've formed complete sentences. If not, it's usually because you're missing an article.

Ledes: Seek Missing Information!

There was a sort of trick question in this exercise, and that would be on the one citing Mayor Datolli.

In journalism, we fully identify people in first referring to them in a story. So in a first reference, it's Omar Sofradzija, with both the first and last name.

In subsequent references, however, you just use the last name: just Sofradzija said, for example.

In this case, though, you weren't given a first name for Datolli. What to do?

As journalists, our job isn't to simply write what is put before us. It's also to seek answers to holes in the information we have.

The correct response would have been to ask me for the mayor's first name. In a real world setting, it would be to find out what the mayor's first name was by making phone calls or checking records or just asking the mayor what the hell her first name was.

Be curious. Don't settle for what you have if what you have leaves unanswered questions.

Ledes: Be Economical With Words

Look for places where you use a bunch of words when fewer words would suffice. And use direct language. Like here:

Erik Barsh is suing the city for last year's lightning accident that happened at a municipal swimming pool which left him severely injured and his friend deceased.

Let's take out "that happened." What's left is this:

Erik Barsh is suing the city for last year's lightning accident at a municipal swimming pool which left him severely injured and his friend deceased.

Does the reader lose anything other than two words? I'd say no. So, if the words don't add anything to the lede, why add the words?

Also, in journalism we try to use direct language. So, instead of saying the accident left his friend deceased, why not just say it left his friend dead?

This next lede had several problems regarding bets word use:

Mayor Datolli proposes a controversial busing systems plan to assist vagrants to move on and out of the city.

First, did you need to say controversial busing systems plan? I would think controversial bus plan would suffice.

Second, how about move on and out? Couldn't you just say move out and not lose any conveyance of meaning?

Third, is it offense to refer to homeless people as vagrants? Let's try to avoid terms that can legitimately be seen as offensive.