Tuesday, November 2, 2010
Stats -- A Few Points . . .
For example, let's look at this passage:
According to the survey, the percentage of today's households with computers has risen 53.6 percent since 1984, with a total of 61.8 percent of people owning computers.
This is a fatal.
How is that? you may say. It went from 8.2 percent in 1984 to 61.8 percent now. The difference is 53.6 percent!
That's because the difference in percentage points is 53.6 percent. But the difference in percentage growth is actually 653.6 percent!
Here's what I mean:
In 1984, 8.2 percent of 100 percent households had computers. If 100 percent is 113.1 million households, that means 8.2 percent is around 9.2 million households.
Today, 61.8 percent of that 113.1 million households have computers. 61.8 percent of 113.1 million is around 69.9 million.
So the percentage increase isn't 8.2 to 53.6; it's roughly 9.2 million to somewhere around 69.9 million. And that's an increase of over 650 percent. If the 9.2 million only went up just over 53 percent, we'd be talking about a total of around 14 million or so.
What I think you meant to say was that the percentage of households with computers has risen 53.67 percentage points. Which it did. But that's not what you said.
If you're not sure, check with your sources to make sure your math is correct and in proper context.
>>> AP Style. It's not 53 %; it's 53 percent, with percent spelled out. C'mon, folks; we've been over that one before.
>>> Who's missing? Three of you did NOT turn in this assignment. If you didn't get a graded copy back from me and you did turn it in, please see me ASAP. If I don't hear from you, you know what your grade will be.
Tuesday, October 26, 2010
Lawsuit -- In General . . .
A few things to note from this assignment:
Don't forget the use of "allegedly." In a lawsuit, nothing is proven yet; all is alleged. So don't skimp on using that disclaimer. One of you wroye that the kid's lack of skills was "in fact due to . . . incompetent teachers." Uh, no! No facts have yet been proven! It's allegedly due to incompetent teachers!
Make sure you have the news in the lede. The news isn't that a lawsuit was filed; it's why, right?
Use AP Style. I know the document said it was the 9th Judicial Circuit, but in AP Style that is Ninth Judicial Circuit. Remember your AP number rules.
One of you didn't name the plaintiffs. I assume it was to protect the identity of a minor. While the policies of newspapers, TV stations and Web sites widely vary on whether or when to use the names of child suspects or victims, rarely does that standard apply to lawsuits where the plaintiffs are seeking mucho dineros.
Don't be redundant. You don't need to say they are suing for compensatory damages of $5000,000; just say they are suing for $500,000. That's what the compensatory damages are; why not just cut to the chase?
Simplify things. One of you wrote that the parents "are pursuing a civil court case against the school district." Why not just say "suing the school district"? Again, cut to the chase and translate legal gobbledygook to simple English.
Watch for unnecessary fatals. One very-nicely written story idnetified the plaintiffs as the Dowells. It was the Dowdells. Nothing to add here, folks. Just pointing it out.
Watch your punctuation. This isn't a grammar class, but I'm concerned about the proper use of apostrophe s's. Lots of incorrect usage in this exercise. You can find a cheat sheet on where to put an apostrophe around an "s" in the AP Stylebook in the chapter titled "A Guide To Punctuation." Under "Punctuation Marks And How To Use Them," read the section under "apostrophe."
Monday, October 25, 2010
Police -- Peanut Barrel
Isn't that a Peanut Barrel-type of story? Isn't that sharp contrast in size what takes an out-of-the-ordinary robbery story (unusual in that the victim beat off the attacker) and make it even more unique?
I'm not shocked that many of you didn't weave it into your ledes, because to do that is doable but a bit complex. I'm just surprised many of you didn't note that bit of interest at all.
So now we have nine students who are part of the Fatals Club. If you count time fatals, it's ten.
That means we have only one person left who hasn't fataled in any way, shape or form this semester.
Sigh.
Police -- Fatals
Paradoxically, that wasn't the problem in this assignment.
In fact, the two people who fataled were the first two people finished with the assignment!
So it wasn't lack of time that caused the fatals. Far from it. The assignments were turned in 31 and 28 minutes, respectively, from the original 11:20 deadline that was extended another 10 minutes.
And the fatals were in the completely-avoidable category. Each person misidentified the store (one mistakenly listed the suspect's place of employment as the crime scene, the other spelled the store as Jimmy -- and not Jiffy -- Foods, another case where spell check wasn't going to catch the problem).
Then, one person spelled "DaRoza" two different ways in the same sentence, while the other claimed the robber escaped with the cash register and $80 in cash, even though the report indicated nothing was actually stolen.
You had time to catch these errors, folks.
If you get done early, PLEASE take a few minutes to do more than your usual fact-checking. Take advantage of ALL the time you have to properly vet a story.
I know you want to get out of here. But you also want to get the grade you deserve, right?
So do the work that's necessary.
Police -- Allegedly
It's not alleged that Keel entered the store. He has a face full of broken bones proving he was there.
What is alleged is whether he pulled a knife, and tried to commit a crime.

So, where does allegedly fit in here?
DaRoza walked behind the counter for the key to the restroom when Keel followed him and exposed a knife.
Before "exposed a knife," right?
Police -- Many of You . . .
You should have. It's news WHERE something happens, right?
Who, what, when, where, why, how.
Thursday, October 21, 2010
911 -- Quotes
Somebody's hurting my mommy.
Hurry. My mommy's crying.
My mommy. What'll happen to my mommy?
I'm afraid. Will he hurt me, too?
Great quotes. They're telling. They set context in a special way -- they sound like things you'd imagine a 6-year-old girl would say, right?
Yet only four of you quoted the girl at all in your articles!
We've talked about the concept of showing and not just telling readers; that is, don't just tell them something happened; show them the proof.
Those quotes are the "show" part. Don't be afraid to use quotes that support and prove your key points.
Also, the quotes also humanize the story. It's not the dry legal jargon of a crime taking place; it's the quivering voice of a scared little girl. It emphasizes people, and when it comes down to it, all stories are not crime stories or business stories or political stories; they are all people stories -- stories about what happened to people, or what people did, or what may affect people.
Let the humanity shine through in your stories, when possible.
911 -- Fatals
The person realized their mistake and sent in a corrected copy. I'm sorry to say that the original copy holds. We have to get it right the first time we turn something in, especially on deadline. There's no stopping the printing press unless it's a real emergency, and you can't restart the 11 o'clock news at 11:03.
This one especially pains me because this was my most common type of fatal when I was a pro: I couldn't get the day of the week right to save my life. Thursdays would feel like Tuesdays, and I'd type in the wrong date like an idiot.
So I got into the habit of religiously checking the date before I turned in a story; even asking peers to take a quick check and see if I got the date right.
I learned that lesson the hard way; after a couple of fatals found their way into the paper. So my heart goes out to you, but I wouldn't be doing you a favor by acting like it's no big deal when in the real world, it is.
Sorry, folks.
We now have eight members of the Fatals Club (nine, if you count me). Three more to go.
911 -- Identification
First, you should have been operating under the general journalistic premise that we do NOT name rape victims in almost all cases.
Yet FOUR of you named the victim. Why?
Then, there is the concern of making a virtual identification; that is, giving so much other information that it is easy for anybody to identify the victim.
Two of you named the victim's daughter. A daughter only has one mother, right? So that's real easy to narrow down. One of you even listed the exact home address. Only one family lives in a home, right? Again, you virtually identified the victim.
Even though an exact address would expose the victim, don't readers deserve to know where a crime took place? I mean, a story is much more relevant if it happened on your street or in your neighborhood than if it didn't. Some location is necessary to establish relevance.
One of you handled it in a smart way: you simply said the incident happened on Wilson Avenue. No street address included. That gave readers enough information to better set proximitry, without giving away the victim's home and creating a virtual identification.
I also thought important to the story was noting that Caspinwall was a neighbor of the victim. Readers need to know if this crime was totally random or if there was some sort of link between the victim and attacker. Readers have more reason to worry if someone is willy-nilly breaking into random homes, as opposed to attacking a neighbor, right?
But only five of you noted the link.
One of you took a different tack in noting the connection but trying to minimize virtual identification: you didn't name the suspect, either. Uh, don't you think that people deserve and need to know the name of somebody who allegedly breaks into homes and rapes people?
Admittedly, this was a confusing exercise. You had many different factors tugging at you. It's really a tough situation for a young reporter to find himself or herself in. In a real-world setting, you'd definitely want to bring an editor in the loop to help make the best judgments that give the readers the most information while at the same time minimizing harm to the victim.
But here, I wanted to test your judgment and see how you responded. And I figured you''d appreciate the lesson much more if we did it this way, as opposed to just lecturing about it.
This is how I would have handled it: I WOULD name the victim or the girl. I WOULD name the suspect and even use HIS home address. I'd say the victim limed nearby, but I wouldn't say they were direct neighbors.
That way, readers know who did this (and know exactly where the sicko lived) and the general area where the crime occurred and that it wasn't a random crime, while at the same time limiting the ability to identify who the victim was.
911 -- Allegedly
Is it alleged that the woman was raped? No. She was raped. Someone broke into her house and raped her. That much was clearly established.
What is alleged is who raped her. A man did, obviously. But it's alleged that it was Andrew Caspinwall.
So you should say Caspinwall allegedly raped the victim. Or the victim was raped, allegedly by Caspinwall.
Rescue -- Was it . . .
Or a tunnel that was a kind of play-fort?
It's the former, right?
So, why call it a fort when it was really a tunnel?
One of you hit the description just right: in the first reference, you called it a make-shift fort; then in the second reference you called it a tunnel.
Rescue -- Attribution
Not Lt. Chenn. Not neighbors and witnesses, The report!
You saw the report, but you didn't talk to anybody yourself, right?
So it was " . . . Chenn said, according to the report."
Or "In the report, Chenn said . . . "
Or " . . . neighbors told Chenn, according to the report."
Make sure you understand your attribution, and that you offer PROPER attribution!
Rescue -- Watch For Illogical Things
The Okemos attorney of fence and the Zoning Board have been notified.
This is what you were paraphrasing:
Notify City Attorney of fence and Zoning Board of possible hazard for children.
What it meant was, the city attorney should be notified about the fence, and the zoning board should be notified about the possible hazard for children.
Your first tip-off that maybe you read it wrong should be been the title of attorney of fence. That makes no snese, right?
If it makes no sense, don't assume. And don't just go with what you have. Check it out!
That example is kinda funny. This next one is not:
The collapse happened at 4:40 p.m. and Lo was freed at 3:24 p.m.
Obviously, you can't be rescued before you get into trouble. So if you were adequately fact-checking what you wrote, that should have tipped you off that you had an incorrect number in there somewhere. (In fact, it was the latter number that was wrong. It should have been 5:24 p.m.)
Sadly, that was a fatal.
e you get into trouble.
Tuesday, October 19, 2010
Meeting -- Ledes
Let's look at some examples:
In an effort to address the growing problem of housing the city's homeless population, the Grand Ledge City Council voted 6-1 yesterday to donate city land to build a new homeless shelter.
It's to-the-point and direct. Here's a good lede/nut graf sequence:
The Grand Ledge City Council voted Monday in favor of donating land on Garland Avenue proposed by the Coalition for the Homeless Inc. as the site for a new homeless shelter.
The city council's 6-1 vote will turn the location of an old fire station valued at $5090,000 into a $1.5 million homeless shelter which the CHI will raise money to construct and provide the working staff.
One of you had your interest drawn to how the vote came about:
The Grand Ledge City Council approved a proposal Sunday by the Coalition for the Homeless Inc. to construct a homeless shelter on Garland Avenue, despite angry opposition from Council Member William Belmonte.
Though Ida Levine, the president of the coalition, assured the council her organization would raise the $1.5 million needed to construct the shelter, Belmonte was not convinced. In an angry outburst, he questioned the ability of the coalition to raise the funds and the effect their failure to do so would have on taxpayers in Grand Ledge.
"Why should taxpayers suddenly start paying for this, people who work hard for their money and are struggling these days to support their families?" he said.
Is this approach better or worse than the others? Or is it just different? Is this the right way to do this story, or are there several "right" ways?
This lede was atop a story that was structured very well, except for the lede. Here it is:
Organization leaders gathered at the city council meeting Monday night to discuss the idea of expanding the First United Methodist Church's basement, used as a homeless shelter that has recently become overwhelmed.
In the fifth graf, it first mentions the plan for a new shelter. And only in the last graf is the council's approval of the plan noted.
In this case, you essentially end the story with your lede: the ultimate outcome. Don't forget that, unlike traditional linear writing, in journalism you START with the ending.
Finally, if you're wondering if your lede is jumbled or is clear enough, do this: read it out loud. Does it sound jumbled? Then unjumble the word order. Does it sound like a complete sentence? If not, add the necessary words.
Read this one out loud:
A triumph for the newly-formed Coalition for the Homeless Inc. Sunday night, as the Grand Ledge City Council affirmed the donation of property on Garland Avenue for a homeless shelter.
What's missing? Perhaps a "There was" at the start?
Meeting -- Write With (AP) Style
It's Lt. AP Style, under "military title," offers a list of such titles that should be abbreviated. Lieutenant is on that list.
Additionally, it offers a subhed of "firefighters, police officers" which says this:
Use the abbreviations listed here when a military-style title is used before the name of a firefighter or police officer outside a direct quotation.
Neutral Experts -- Imagine This Story . . .
O'Donnell questions separation of church, state
WILMINGTON, Del. – Republican Senate nominee Christine O'Donnell of Delaware on Tuesday questioned whether the U.S. Constitution calls for a separation of church and state, appearing to disagree or not know that the First Amendment bars the government from establishing religion.
The exchange came in a debate before an audience of legal scholars and law students at Widener University Law School, as O'Donnell criticized Democratic nominee Chris Coons' position that teaching creationism in public school would violate the First Amendment by promoting religious doctrine.
Coons said private and parochial schools are free to teach creationism but that "religious doctrine doesn't belong in our public schools."
"Where in the Constitution is the separation of church and state?" O'Donnell asked him.
When Coons responded that the First Amendment bars Congress from making laws respecting the establishment of religion, O'Donnell asked: "You're telling me that's in the First Amendment?"
Her comments, in a debate aired on radio station WDEL, generated a buzz in the audience.
"You actually audibly heard the crowd gasp," Widener University political scientist Wesley Leckrone said after the debate, adding that it raised questions about O'Donnell's grasp of the Constitution.
Erin Daly, a Widener professor who specializes in constitutional law, said that while there are questions about what counts as government promotion of religion, there is little debate over whether the First Amendment prohibits the federal government from making laws establishing religion.
"She seemed genuinely surprised that the principle of separation of church and state derives from the First Amendment, and I think to many of us in the law school that was a surprise," Daly said. "It's one thing to not know the 17th Amendment or some of the others, but most Americans do know the basics of the First Amendment."
O'Donnell didn't respond to reporters who asked her to clarify her views after the debate.
During the exchange, she said Coons' views on creationism showed that he believes in big-government mandates.
"Talk about imposing your beliefs on the local schools," she said. "You've just proved how little you know not just about constitutional law but about the theory of evolution."
Coons said her comments show a "fundamental misunderstanding" of the Constitution.
The debate, their third in the past week, was more testy than earlier ones.
O'Donnell began by defending herself for not being able to name a recent Supreme Court decision with which she disagrees at a debate last week. She said she was stumped because she largely agrees with the court's recent decisions under conservative chief justices John Roberts and William Rehnquist.
"I would say this court is on the right track," she said.
The two candidates repeatedly talked over each other, with O'Donnell accusing Coons of caving at one point when he asked the moderator to move on to a new question after a lengthy argument.
"I guess he can't handle it," she said.
O'Donnell, a tea party favorite who stunned the state by winning the GOP primary last month in her third Senate bid in five years, called Coons a liberal "addicted to a culture of waste, fraud and abuse."
Coons, who has held a double-digit lead in recent polls, urged voters to support him as the candidate of substance, with a track record over six years as executive of the state's most populous county. He said O'Donnell's only experience is in "sharpening the partisan divide but not at bridging it."
Speech -- I Am An Idiot
I fataled. If you're wondering how, let me explain:
After uploading blog posts about the speech assignment, one of you took an early sneak-peek and noted that I fataled somebody for saying the speech took place two days before Halloween. I fataled it, noting that in the preface it simply said the event was a few days before Halloween.
What I missed -- and what you caught -- was that in the text, the surgeon general said this:
"In just two days many of our young people will be celebrating Halloween."
Yes, I completely missed it. Yes, in this instance I failed to do the due diligence that I implore each and every one of you to do each and every time. That is my fault. There is no excuse.
If any good comes out of this, I hope this highlights that it simply doesn't matter how experienced you are at being a journalist; you have to do the fundamentals each time and every time. You can't take short cuts because you're busy or in a hurry or tired or because you think you know what you're doing. There are things you can find ways to do faster in journalism, but you can never skip a step in the process. You have to do the little things every time out.
My thanks to the person who tipped me off to this and saved somebody else's grade. You did the right thing; you double-checked a fact and brought attention to a claim not supported by the facts. That's a good journalistic action. That's what we do, right?
If your mother says she loves you, check it out. And if the teacher says it's a fatal, check that out, too. The worst thing that happens is that you confirm I'm right, and the best thing that happens is that you find -- and, more importantly -- fix -- a mistake.
You may flog me now. And no, it doesn't mean I'll take it easy on finding and noting future fatals on your part.
Monday, October 18, 2010
Speech -- If This Were A Real Story . . .
Speech -- Lotsa Good News!
You didn't have a lot of time to figure that out. You were on deadline.
Still, you did your job. Congrats! Let's look at some of the ledes. Tell me which ones you liked the best, and why:
In a speech delivered Sunday night at a Michigan PTA Convention in Detroit, U.S. Surgeon General Tom Izzo addressed the issue of underage drinking as a problematic element of the Halloween season.
(Suggestion: first, why not get rid of the unwieldy "addressed the issue of" and replace it with a "called," like this:)
In a speech delivered Sunday night at a Michigan PTA Convention in Detroit, U.S. Surgeon General Tom Izzo called underage drinking a problematic element of the Halloween season.
(I'd also consider flipping the lede to emphasize what was said over who said it, but I wouldn't say a flip was necessary, especially if you wanted to emphasize the speaker's status. Let's move on now and look at another lede.)
The surgeon general of the U.S. Public Health Service, Tom Izzo, addressed the issue of the alcohol industry targeting Halloween as a marketing opportunity at a PTA convention in Detroit Sunday night.
(Again, I think this one is a bit heavy with unnecessary words. I'd flip the sequencing of Izzo's title and replace "addressed the issue of" with "alleged," as in Izzo was making an allegation, like this:)
U.S. Public Health Service Surgeon General Tom Izzo alleged the alcohol industry is targeting Halloween as a marketing opportunity at a PTA convention in Detroit Sunday night.
(One other thing; watch your statement placement. Read it literally, it says "the alcohol industry targeting Halloween as a marketing opportunity at a PTA convention in Detroit." That's not what you meant to say, is it? Perhaps the "where" (PTA convention in Detroit) should have been paired next to the who (Izzo) to avoid any potential confusion.
More ledes here:
Just days before Halloween, U.S. Surgeon General Tom Izzo spoke in Detroit Sunday night about the harmful role the alcohol industry plays in the lives of America's youth.
This one brings some different context: it was just before the holiday, which makes the speech more relevant and useful than if it was the day before Easter, for example.
Next:
The alcohol industry is targeting Halloween, a traditional children's holiday, to market their products to a young audience, according to the nation's surgeon general who spoke at a convention in Detroit Sunday evening.
Again, we get context here with the "traditional children's holiday" mention. Next:
Surgeon General Tom Izzo took a stance against alcohol companies' efforts to target Halloween as their latest marketing opportunity.
Straight and to the point, right? Those are juts a few of some really good ones.
Speech -- And Some Bad News
Two people had misspellings inside of a quote that changed the meaning of the quote. One said kids were "robed" when what was meant was that kids were "robbed." And the other said Halloween and "hobs" do not mix, when "hops" was meant.
BTW, I had no idea before now, but "hob" is an actual word. It's a noun, meaning several things:
1. A shelf or projection at the back or the inside off a fireplace, used for keeping things warm.
2. A tool used for cutting the teeth of machine parts, as of a gearwheel
3. A hobgoblin, sprite or elf
Seriously. Page 615 of The American Heritage Dictionary, Second College Edition.
Every day is a learning experience, I guess.
Please learn to carefully double-check your work, folks.