Friday, June 3, 2011
Speech -- What Is The News?
Speech -- Fatals Suck
Speech -- The Missing "He Said"
Speech -- Avoid The First Person
Speech -- Write With (AP) Style ...
In this instance, it's the latter. In AP Style under dates . . .
Always use Arabic figures, without st, nd, rd or th. See months for examples . . .
Also, under months . . .
Capitalize the names of months in all uses. When a month is used with a specific date, abbreviate only Jan., Feb., Aug., Sept., Oct., Nov. and Dec. Spell out when using alone, or with a year alone.
So two should be two, not 2. And 10 should be 10, not ten.
So then, is this correct to start a sentence, under AP Style rules?
Forty . . .
Actually, that IS correct number use. This is under the numerals heading:
Spell out a numeral at the beginning of a sentence.
Now, there are situations where you have a number that would be very awkward to spell out. Like with very large numbers, like 3,158. I would suggest not using such a number at the start of a sentence.Or start such a sentence with attribution so the number conflict doesn't matter (e.g., "According to Izzo, 3,158 ... ) or a generality (e.g., More than 3,000 people ... ).
It's the middle one. AP Style, under grade, grader:
Hyphenate in combining forms: a fourth-grade pupil, a 12th-grade student, first-grader, 10th-grader.
Note there is no exception made from the general AP numbers rule of spell out numbers under 10, and use digits for 10 and above. Also note that the examples given appear to adhere to that rule.
Now, in first reference is it PTA or Parent-Teacher Association? Did anybody look under PTA?
Thursday, June 2, 2011
JRN 200 -- What Does My Grade Mean?
4.0: Story could be published virtually as is. It shows superior command of the facts, news judgment, story organization, reporting and writing.
3.5: Could be published with very minor revisions. Generally well-written, accurate copy containing all relevant material, but requires minor editing for maximum precision and clarity.
3.0: Better-than-average story. The story was handled well. Copy needs some rewriting and polishing before it could be published.
2.5: A little above average. The story might have a significant problem with reporting, organization, completeness, ect. Certainly needs rewriting.
2.0: Average job. Not a story most readers would read unless they really needed the information. The story may have reporting, organization or writing problems.
1.5: A weak story. The story may have a buried lede, problems in news interpretation, problems in story organization, omission of some important fact or source. The story needs substantial revision.
1.0: A non-story. The story lacks news judgment, displays major flaws in reporting and writing, omits important facts. The story needs substantial rethinking.
0.0: Story is late or failed to receive instructor's approval. Story is misleading or unethical. Organization of writing flaws make the story incoherent.
Squirrels -- The Mystery Of The Missing Nut Graf
Squirrels -- How Did You Know That?
One problem area, though, was attribution. Many of you failed to have an adequate level of attribution. Not uncommon for a young reporter, but something that needs to be fixed, pronto.
For example, how do you know Brookes spent $184 to get his car's wiring replaced?
Were you there when he had the wiring replaced? No.
Did you pay for the repair bill? No.
So, how do you know?
It's because he said so, right?
So, why not let readers know your sourcing? Brookes said he spent $184 to get his car's wiring replaced?
How do you know Kasparov was driving home one night when her car fritzed out? Because she said! So add "she said" as attribution.
How do you know how her mechanic found squirrels under the hood? Because she said!
Pretty much everything not witnessed by you should have some sort of attribution. He said; she said; according to records; whatever.
Make sure you have properly attributed everything in your story. Basically, every paragraph after the lede and nut graf should have some sort of attribution affixed to it.
I know that's gonna look a bit weird, having graf after graf with so-and-so said this and this other dude said that and so on. But we do it as journalists to make sure that readers know exactly where we got our information. It promotes transparency and illustrates the factual basis for a story.
Over the next few days, when you're doing your daily newspaper readings please note attribution. See how frequent it is. See how writers offer it. Get a sense of how it's supposed to look in a finished product.
Squirrels -- Write With (AP) Style
In general, use last names only on second reference.
But how do you handle subsequent references?
You have a few options. One is to refer to the college in the generic, like I just did: as the college, lower-cased.
A second option would be to consider using an acronym, if there is a common acronym for the group. An acronym is a word formed from the first letter or letters of a series of words, such as MSU (which is the acronym for Michigan State University). Or, in this case, LCC.
If an acronym is well-known -- like NASA or FBI or USA -- then generally it is acceptable in a second reference, or even in a first reference.
This is where I'm going to refer you back to AP Style. Please carefully read and review the listing for abbreviations and acronyms.
In general, confine capitalization to formal titles used directly before an individual's name.
That means, if you are referring to the a professor in the generic, then it's lower-case:
Regarding squirrels, the professor said they suck.
If you are adding the title before the name, then you do capitalize:
Regarding squirrels, Professor Oliver Brookes said they suck.
But if you do not directly connect the name and title, then the title remains lower-case.
Regarding squirrels, Oliver Brookes -- who is a professor -- said they suck.
Please review AP Style under titles.
Hockey -- Overall
And that's okay. First assignments are always the toughest, because you don't have anything to compare them to.
You're not exactly sure how to lay out a story and organize facts. You've had only theoretical discussions to date.
But in journalism, we learn by doing. And then having that work critiqued, so I can highlight what you did well,and what could be improved upon, and how to do better the next time around.
The sort of mistakes I saw this time around are on par for what trips up a young journalist: your paragraphs are too big. Attribution is lacking. Fatals creep up here and there. There's a bit of excessive wordiness.
No one loves seeing a lot of red ink on their papers. But red ink, right now, is a good thing. It means we're finding out what we need to work on, and we're working on solutions to those issues.
So don't fret, no matter how you did on our first few assignments. We have a long way to go, and you'll have plenty of opportunities to show me your improvement in the coming weeks.
Wednesday, June 1, 2011
Hockey -- Good Nut Grafs
Hockey -- Anecdotal Ledes
Hockey -- Fatals
In one case, you misspelled the last name of board member Jane Tribitt, which you spelled correctly two references but as Tribett in the third. This one was completely catchable if you did your due diligence in double-checking every name, asserion, quote, figure, statistic, ect. after you finished writing.
Hockey -- Avoid Empty Grafs
Hockey -- Grafs Are Too Big!
That is NOT how we write in journalism.
In journalism, grafs are much more bite-sized. And there's a reason for that. Each graf should contain just ONE central point, or ONE supporting fact. It should be easy for a reader to be able to break down the informational subsets you offer, and it should be easy for an editor to be able to skim through your story and identify each idea and piece of evidence broken out into its own paragraph.
In general, that means you should often end up with most paragraphs being no longer than two sentences, and quite often just one sentence long.
Let's look at this:
In a 9-0 vote Tuesday evening, the local school board unanimously decided to ban boys from playing on girls’ sports teams in the district. Effective immediately, boys will be banned from playing on the girls’ field hockey, softball, and volleyball teams. Although the new policy is largely unpopular with many students and parents, the school board stands by its decision, citing the size, speed, and power of male athletes and its potential hazards to female players.
That's just too much, and too long. All the information is mushed in together. It's hard to differentiate key points. But to make the story cleaner and easier to read, all you had to do was hit the "return" key a couple of times, like this:
In a 9-0 vote Tuesday evening, the local school board unanimously decided to ban boys from playing on girls’ sports teams in the district.
Effective immediately, boys will be banned from playing on the girls’ field hockey, softball, and volleyball teams.
Although the new policy is largely unpopular with many students and parents, the school board stands by its decision, citing the size, speed, and power of male athletes and its potential hazards to female players.
Now, key points stand out: what happened (in the first lede graf), the details of how it's being implemented (in the second nut graf) and an explanation of why it's needed in the first place (the third graf). Now do you see what I mean by separating units of thoughts and main points?
Same thing with the relationship between a point and supporting information, like here:
High school Athletic Director Hugh Baker worried that the new ruling will force teams, like the girls field hockey team, to forfeit because of other teams in the league that have boys on them. “Our girls field hockey team would have had to forfeit at least ten of their 18 games last season because we played other schools that had boys on their teams,” Baker said.
Once again, you can divide the point being made in the paraphrase, and the evidence via the quote, like this:
High school Athletic Director Hugh Baker worried that the new ruling will force teams, like the girls field hockey team, to forfeit because of other teams in the league that have boys on them.
“Our girls field hockey team would have had to forfeit at least ten of their 18 games last season because we played other schools that had boys on their teams,” Baker said.
Again, do you see how it clearly differentiates between one unit of information (the point being made via paraphrase) and the supporting evidence for the unit (the quote)?
You may notice in your returned work that I may have peppered your paper with what appears to be a red-ink capital L. That's the copyediting symbol for where you should have ideally started a new paragraph.
Hockey -- Attribute!
Of course not. You know that because East Lansing Athletic Difrector Hugh Baker said that.
So, it's not enough to offer a graf saying this:
East Lansing High may have to forfeit games next year to avoid playing mixed-gender teams.
You'd need to say something like this, if first referring to Baker:
East Lansing High may have to forfeit games next year to avoid playing mixed-gender teams, school athletic director Hugh Baker said.
Or this, if it's a secondary reference to Baker:
East Lansing High may have to forfeit games next year to avoid playing mixed-gender teams, Baker said.
Don't leave readers wondering where you got your information. Offer attribution! Make sure that every graf after the lede has some form of adequate attribution.
Neutral Experts -- Why They Matter
Think of it in terms of a game: you normally have one side and the other side, right? How you view the game depends on which side you're on. Unless you have a referee, that is. A neutral expert is sort of a referee, helping point on when one side is telling the truth and the other side is stretching it a bit -- or a lot.
Most news stories at least attempt to include at least one neutral expert. And I would bet almost all of your first out-of-class stories would benefit from having a neutral expert included.
You can find a neutral expert about almost anything, no matter how obscure. Let's look at this example: during the run-up to the 2008 presidential election, a lot was made about how the Obamas would fist-bump each other. The New York Times Sunday Magazine even did a story about it.
Here's how the story started:
Is this the end of high-five?
On the night in June that Barack Obama clinched the Democratic nomination, he and his wife, Michelle, exchanged what was variously described as a “closed-fist high five,” a “fist pound,” a “knuckle buckle” and a “fist jab.” Jonathan Tilove in The New Orleans Times-Picayune called the gesture “the dap heard ’round the world,” which he felt encapsulated “the new cultural trajectory of American politics.”
Believe it or not, they found an expert on fist-bumping. And that expert is right here. Let's continue the story:
Prof. Geneva Smitherman, director of African-American language study atMichigan State University, says: “Pound is when knuckles touch in a horizontal position. That’s the gesture that Michelle and Barack used. Dap is when the knuckles touch in a vertical position. Both gestures can be used as a greeting, to signal respect, agreement, bonding.”
Dap started among black soldiers during the Vietnam War; to give “some dap” (not usually “a” dap) means “to offer kudos, congratulations”; Prof. James Peterson of Bucknell, a hip-hop historian, says he thinks it is rooted in dapper, “neat, fashionably smart.” Pound came out of hip-hop in the late 1980s. Fist bump came later: a 1996 note in the Sports Network wire service reported that Eddie Murray of the Baltimore Orioles was accepting congratulations from baseball teammates with “high-fives, handshakes or fist bumps.” Peterson says the new phrase robs the gesture of its cultural significance, which includes the Obamas’ “quiet but pronounced in-group affiliation with all of black America.”
Hand signals have a checkered history in politics, from Prime Minister Winston Churchill’s V-for-victory sign to the famed photo of Gov. Nelson Rockefeller “giving the finger” to hecklers to the clenched-fist salute of “black power” to Lyndon Johnson’s fondness for “pressing the flesh.”
When Michelle Obama visited Barbara Walters on “The View” on ABC, the candidate’s wife sought to soften her image with “I have to be greeted properly. Fist bump, please. It is now my signature bump. . . . I got it from the young staff. That’s the new high-five.”
Colleges are notorious for being loaded with neutral experts (think of all your profs doing research, and all the TA's working on their thesis papers!) So really, there's no excuse for you NOT to find a neutral expert, especially here or at other schools.Like many other schools, MSU -- in hopes of getting free publicity -- even makes it easy to find experts. The MSU News Office's Web site has an experts list, which you can link to here:http://news.msu.edu/experts/Results/?
Just looking at the first page, these are just some of the topics for which MSU can find you a neutral expert: wind power, renewable energy, water preservation, breast cancer, breast cancer education, medical education, microfinance, filmmaking, documentary production, sensors and nano-bisensor devices for biodefense, health diagnostics and theraputics, child welfare, biblical references and history, Samartian population, meteorology and climatology, Isreali-Palestinian conflict, Israeli politics, society and culture, international relations, U.S. foreign policy, school funding, school choice, school district building projects, the effects of mass communications, health communications, communications campaigns, international relations, the Middle East, Muslim issues, the early formation of galaxies, tax and expenditure policies, state and local public finance, poverty and income distribution, campus sustainability, Internet governance, new wireless technologies, telecommunications regulation and policy, bone and tissue engineering, labor markets, chaos theory, alternative dispute resolution, primitive stars, galaxy formation, labor unions and collective bargaining, international and domestic labor policy, work and family policy, flexible scheduling policy, tropical diseases, malaria, AIDS/HIV . . .
. . . and those are just a FEW of the subject areas!
You can also search by typing in a topic here: http://news.msu.edu/experts/
I took some general topics and looked for experts. Like Google, sometimes you have to try the same general term in different ways (like if you're searching for an expert in campus safety, you try that term, then campus, then safety, then police, and so on).
Under "campus living" I found one expert. For "transportation" I found two. There were three each for "housing" and "discrimination" and "elections." I found four each for "police" and "campus" and "drug." For "safety" I found 14! And "health" produced 35!
And you can filter by these general topic areas: agriculture and environment; arts and humanities; athletics; board and administration; business, economy, law and communications; education; family and social issues; health, medicine and veterinary medicine; international; science and technology; staff and faculty; students and campus life; tuition, costs and enrollment.
Plus, there's always Google, right? And other schools as well. And think tanks. And private research institutions.
Wherever you find a good one, it's critical that you do. Journalism isn't about just getting both sides of the story. Getting one side and the other side and nothing else is just enabling a fight.
We're about trying to arrive at a verifiable version of the truth based on facts and checking out what people have to say, right? That's the role a neutral expert helps accomplish.
To paraphrase legendary baseball announcer and willful drunk Harry Caray -- and this might be the only smart thing he ever said in his life, God rest his soul -- there are three sides to every story: your side, my side, and the truth.
We need to get more than two out of three. We need all of 'em.
So go find some neutral experts!
Neutral Experts -- Imagine This Story ...
O'Donnell questions separation of church, state
WILMINGTON, Del. – Republican Senate nominee Christine O'Donnell of Delaware on Tuesday questioned whether the U.S. Constitution calls for a separation of church and state, appearing to disagree or not know that the First Amendment bars the government from establishing religion.
The exchange came in a debate before an audience of legal scholars and law students at Widener University Law School, as O'Donnell criticized Democratic nominee Chris Coons' position that teaching creationism in public school would violate the First Amendment by promoting religious doctrine.
Coons said private and parochial schools are free to teach creationism but that "religious doctrine doesn't belong in our public schools."
"Where in the Constitution is the separation of church and state?" O'Donnell asked him.
When Coons responded that the First Amendment bars Congress from making laws respecting the establishment of religion, O'Donnell asked: "You're telling me that's in the First Amendment?"
Her comments, in a debate aired on radio station WDEL, generated a buzz in the audience.
"You actually audibly heard the crowd gasp," Widener University political scientist Wesley Leckrone said after the debate, adding that it raised questions about O'Donnell's grasp of the Constitution.
Erin Daly, a Widener professor who specializes in constitutional law, said that while there are questions about what counts as government promotion of religion, there is little debate over whether the First Amendment prohibits the federal government from making laws establishing religion.
"She seemed genuinely surprised that the principle of separation of church and state derives from the First Amendment, and I think to many of us in the law school that was a surprise," Daly said. "It's one thing to not know the 17th Amendment or some of the others, but most Americans do know the basics of the First Amendment."
O'Donnell didn't respond to reporters who asked her to clarify her views after the debate.
During the exchange, she said Coons' views on creationism showed that he believes in big-government mandates.
"Talk about imposing your beliefs on the local schools," she said. "You've just proved how little you know not just about constitutional law but about the theory of evolution."
Coons said her comments show a "fundamental misunderstanding" of the Constitution.
The debate, their third in the past week, was more testy than earlier ones.
O'Donnell began by defending herself for not being able to name a recent Supreme Court decision with which she disagrees at a debate last week. She said she was stumped because she largely agrees with the court's recent decisions under conservative chief justices John Roberts and William Rehnquist.
"I would say this court is on the right track," she said.
The two candidates repeatedly talked over each other, with O'Donnell accusing Coons of caving at one point when he asked the moderator to move on to a new question after a lengthy argument.
"I guess he can't handle it," she said.
O'Donnell, a tea party favorite who stunned the state by winning the GOP primary last month in her third Senate bid in five years, called Coons a liberal "addicted to a culture of waste, fraud and abuse."
Coons, who has held a double-digit lead in recent polls, urged voters to support him as the candidate of substance, with a track record over six years as executive of the state's most populous county. He said O'Donnell's only experience is in "sharpening the partisan divide but not at bridging it."
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.Attribution -- Paraphrases Are Not Quotes
"People think we make $3 million or $5 million a year." They don't realize most athletes make only $500,000, the ballplayer said.
What some of you did was change the second part of that statement into a quote. But it was not a quote. It was a paraphrase. Turning it into a quote was inaccurate. What you should have done was package a quote and paraphrase together, along something like these lines:
"People think we make $3 million or $5 million a year" and don't realize most athletes make only $500,000, the ballplayer said.
Be sure not to confuse quotes with paraphrases.
Attribution -- It's SAID
It's not "she responded." It's "she said."
It's not "she continued." It's "she said."
'Nuff said on that.
Plus, the attribution is better at the start or end of a quote, and not in the middle of a quote unless separating two sentences. So instead of doing this:
"Only through self-discipline," he said, "can you achieve freedom."
. . . you are better off doing this:
"Only through self-discipline can you achieve freedom," he said.