Wednesday, October 13, 2010

Bicyclist -- Watch Your Wordiness

There are ways to be more efficient in your use of words. For example, watch redundancies and opportunities to combine thoughts.

Let's look at this lede:

A local bike enthusiast and McDonald's manager was released from the hospital two days ago from the hospital two days ago from Mueller Memorial after being hit by a car.

"The hospital" and "Mueller Memorial" are the same thing. So why not say this:

A local bike enthusiast and McDonald's manager was released from the hospital two days ago from Mueller Memorial Hospital two days ago after being hit by a car.

A bit more clear, right?

Also, quite often "that" is an unnecessary word. Let's look at this passage (with all references to "that" in caps):

Taylor said THAT her condition actually got worse before getting better. She said THAT she developed complications after being moved to a rehab facility and then doctors discovered THAT she had some internal injuries.

Let's take out the "thats" and see what happens:

Taylor said her condition actually got worse before getting better. She said she developed complications after being moved to a rehab facility and then doctors discovered she had some internal injuries.

Does it change the meaning whatsoever?

Bicyclist -- Writing With (AP) Style

Is it 72nd St. and Southland Blvd.? Or 72nd Street and Southland Boulevard? Or Seventy-Second Street?

In this case, it was 72nd Street and Southland Boulevard. From AP Style, under "addresses":

Use the abbreviations Ave., Blvd. and St. only with a numbered address: 1600 Pennsylvania Ave. Spell them out and capitalize when part of a formal street name without a number: Pennsylvania Avenue. Lowercase and spell out when used alone or with more than one street name: Massachusetts and Pennsylvania avenues.

Spell out and capitalize First through Ninth when used as street names; use figures with two letters for 10th and above: 7 Fifth Ave., 100 21st St.

Bicyclist -- What is the news . . .

. . . in this lede?

Long-time bicyclist Marsha Taylor spoke this morning following her release from a four-month-long hospital stay after a bicycling accident nearly left her paralyzed.

The lede tells me that the news is that she spoke. But that's not the news; the news is what she said, right?

Think back to the football story situation we often talked about at the start of this semester. The news from a football game isn't that a game was played; it's what happened at the game; who won or lost, and why.

Borrowing from some of the other ledes, I'd say the news was that she said was anxious to start riding again. So a better version of this lede could be something like this:

Long-time bicyclist Marsha Taylor said she is anxious to ride again following her release from a four-month-long hospital stay after a bicycling accident nearly left her paralyzed.

Bicyclist -- Attribution

Most people are getting the hang of attribution; some of you are not.

It's important to attribute where you got your information throughout your story, and repeatedly if necessary.

How did you know Taylor was riding her bike down 72nd Street? You weren't there, were you? Of course not. She told you she was.

So a paragraph with that bit of info needs a "she said" somewhere.

How do you know she partook in bike tours? Again, it's because she told you. The graf containing that statement needs a "she said."

I'm going to reemphasize a pretty good rule of thumb: pretty much every paragraph should cite a source. Pretty much every fact should have a source citation nearby.

If in any single graf you are using just a single source, a single attribution somewhere in the graf is sufficient.

I know when it's a story where you interviewed just one person, it might seem weird having graf after graf all end in "she said."

But your readers don't know you spoke with just one source. And they do want to know how you know what you know.

So be transparent with your readers about how you got your information, and attribute.

Bicyclist -- More Spell Check Non-Catches

The spell check was cool with you referring to a gull bladder.

I'm pretty sure you meant gall bladder, and not the bladder of a sea-faring bird.

Spell check is an aid to - but not a substitute for -- rigorously reviewing your copy. Line by line, word by word, fact by fact.

Tuesday, October 12, 2010

Out of Class Story #1 -- Tell me . . .

. . . how was it?

What surprised you?

What stumped you?

What did you discover?

What did you like about the assignment? What did you like not so much?

What will you do different next time? What will you do again?

Let's try to share good ideas and warn others about pitfalls.

Drowning -- Red Marks

At this point in the term, you may be getting many of your papers back with lots and lots of red ink all over your work. Red pen marks where I point out things that didn't work so well and offer ideas on what you could have done better.

And that's a good thing! Red ink is good!

Seriously, I'm not trying to give you a BS pep talk. Red ink really IS good.

In journalism, we learn by doing, then reviewing, and then applying any and all lessons learned going forward. Red ink helps you do that by pointing out the good and the could-be-better. Red ink helps you identify where you need to keep working and improving. Red ink gives you feedback that is critical at this point to your development as a journalist.

So don't freak out. Red ink is good. Just make sure you are carefully reading and evaluating my critiques; learning whatever lessons you can; and applying what you learn the next time out.

Drowning -- Peanut Barrel Rule

On Monday, I told you that this was an exercise that's usually tripped up previous 200 classes.

And this one did the same here, but not in the way I expected.

In the past, people had trouble with the concept of ledeing with the latest news and properly backgrounding the story so that readers had sufficient background info, which is defined as this: enough information with which to make sense of the latest news.

You aced that. But where many of you went off the rails was in identifying what was the latest AND biggest news. I didn't expect that.

Many of your ledes were like this one:

East Lansing police this morning released the name of the man who drowned yesterday in Nichols Lake in Lakeside Park.

. . . or like this one . . .

The name of the unidentified man who lost his life attempting to rescue a young boy from Nichols Lake Sunday has been released today by the East Lansing Police Department.

Let's lean on the Peanut Barrel rule: what are you most likely to say first? That the name of the dead rescuer was released? Or that the boy he was trying to save died today? What do you think?

I'd say the latter is clearly more impactful and newsworthy than the release of a name. The latter (a death) is clearly a more momentous happening than the former (the release of a name of someone we already know is dead and isn't a particularly well-known public figure of any sort).

So I liked this lede much better:

Edward McGorwan, a boy who was in critical condition overnight related to a drowning accident, has died this morning, according to Dr. Catrina Lowrie, a physician at the Regional Medical Center.

Of course, the best lede would try to incorporate BOTH latest happenings, while giving preference to the death over the naming. That's what this lede did:

A local boy was pronounced dead today after he was pulled out of Nichols Lake unconscious yesterday, and police released the victim's name who drowned while trying to save him.

. . . and so did this one . . .

A doctor announced this morning that Edward McGorwan, the boy rescued from Nichols Lake yesterday, is now dead. His attempted rescuer has also been identified.

One thing about that last lede: I think it would have been better if you had flipped the lede to put the new up front and the attribution second, like this:

Edward McGorwan, the boy rescued from Nichols Lake yesterday, is now dead, a doctor announced this morning. His attempted rescuer has also been identified.

See how that cuts to the chase better?

Drowning -- A Reminder

Some of you weren't here Monday, so you may or may not have seen this item in the blog. It's important that you read this and know this if you want to avoid fataling the rest of teh way out. Here we go:

Some of you are still penning ledes that are way too long. Ledes that are mushed together with nut grafs. Ledes that are waaaaay over the 32 words or so we're trying to maintain for now.

So, here's a new rule. It's in caps and bold-faced so it's unmistakable:

ALL LEDES FOR PRACTICE STORY AND TEST STORY EXERCISES MUST BE NO MORE THAN 32 WORDS UNTIL FURTHER NOTICE!!!

ANY LEDES IN A PRACTICE STORY OR A TEST STORY THAT EXCEEDS THAT LIMIT WILL BE CONSIDERED A FATAL, AND YOU WILL RECEIVE A ZERO ON THAT EXERCISE.

I'M NOT KIDDING, FOLKS!!!

I'm not doing this to be an ass. But ledes are supposed to be brief and to the point. A lede that's 40 or 50 words is neither brief nor to the point.

And a big part of journalism is decision-making; that is, sorting through endless information and prioritizing and summarizing for the reader what is most important. If I allow you to do runaway ledes, you won't develop good decision-making habits. And that will catch up with you at some point; maybe not in this class, and probably at a time when the stakes for you will be much higher.

So we're not going to let that happen. We're going to work out your bad habits and instill some good habits. And that's gonna start with a 32-word cap on ledes.

(For some of you, it's not even a question of needing to develop a lede; you already have a good lede, but it's mushed together with the nut graf and a supporting graf. We just need to make sure you know where to find the "return" key on your keyboard. Here's a good rule of thumb: if you have a lede -- or any paragraph, for that matter -- that's more than one sentence, take a look and see if it's one unit of thought or one piece of information supporting that unit of thought. If it's more than one unit of any of the above, then split it up into separate grafs.)

If anyone needs ANY help in developing ledes, let's schedule some office hours to work on it. I don't expect you to figure this out on your own, but I do expect you to identify what you're having problems with and seek the appropriate remedial help.

Drowning -- Don't Use Euphemisms

Like here:

It was also announced that McGorwan had passed this morning, according to . . .

Use language that is clear and to the point.

The person died. Just say they died.

Drowing -- Write With (AP) Style

On second reference, is it Dr. Lowrie and Officer Linn? Or Lowrie and Linn?

AP Style, under "doctors":

Use Dr. in first reference as a formal title . . . do not continue to use of Dr. in subsequent references.

AP Style, under "military titles":

On first reference, use the appropriate title before the full name . . . in subsequent references, do not continue using the title before a name. Use only the last name.

On second reference of young Edward McGorwan, is it McGorwan or Edward or Edward McGorwan? Here's AP Style, under "names":

In general, use last names only on second reference.

When it is necessary to distinguish between two people who use the same last name, as in married couples or brothers and sisters, use the first and last name.

In stories involving youngsters, generally refer to them by first name on second reference if they are 15 or younger and by their surname at 18 and older.

However, use news judgment and refer to children under 15 by their last name if the story is a serious one involving, for example, a major crime. With the 16- or 17-year-olds, use the surname unless it's a light-hearted story.

So, given the circumstances in this case, what is the way to go?

And is it navy, or Navy?

Look it up and tell me.

Monday, October 11, 2010

Robbery -- Peanut Barrel Rule

There were plenty of good ledes in the exercise you did Monday. People adhered to the 32-word lede limit we have in place right now, and you made some good decisions on how to best use the space you were alloted in creating the highest and best ledes possible.

But some were better than others. Here was an acceptable lede:

Michael Layoux shot and killed the man who had just robbed the convenience store he worked at late last night.

It gets the basics of the story correct. It's not wrong by any means. But it's missing context.

Think about the Peanut Barrel rule: would you first tell friends that someone working at a store shot someone robbing the store, and leave it at that?

No, I think you'd throw in what made this story unique and different from other robbery stories. You tried that with these two ledes here:

Michael Layoux, a clerk at the O-Mart convenience store in Haslett, made a decision against company policy. That decision may have saved his life.

. . . and . . .

During his shift late yesterday, an employee of the O-Mart convenience store in Haslett shot and killed a man attempting to rob the store, but will not be charged for his death.

These are good ledes. Really good ledes. Concise, contextual, the whole shebang. But let's put it up against the Peanut Barrel rule again: is whatever really, really made this story stand out in these ledes? Are these the best ledes you can come up with?

I think you can take it a step better. My gut tells me that what really made this story the most unique is that the clerk legally defended himself -- and lost his job for saving his own life!

This lede hit that sweet spot:

A student at Lansing Community College was fired from a convenience store in Haslett after shooting a man who was in the process of robbing the store.

Very good. But the ledes I thought were best captured ALL the dynamic elements in clear, clean language:

An attempted theft was foiled late yesterday at a Haslett convenience store when the clerk on duty shot and killed the robber in self-defense, resulting in the loss of his job.

. . . and . . .

After shooting and killing a man in self-defense, a Lansing Community College student was fired from his job after the Haslett convenience store he worked at was robbed late yesterday.

Still, I think I could top those ledes. The one point missing was the connection between saving his life and losing his job. If I decided to go straight with little color, I'd do this:

A Haslett convenience store clerk won't face charges for shooting and killing a would-be robber, but he lost his job for violating company rules of possessing handguns on the job. (And it's only 31 words!)

Or if I wanted to get a bit colorful:

The same actions that allowed Michael Layoux to save his own life also cost him his job.

. . . or . . .

Michael Layoux didn't break the law when he shot and killed a robber last night. But he did break a company rule, and that will cost him his job.

How do my ledes adhere to the Peanut Barrel rule? Which works best, and why? Your turn to critique me.

Robbery -- Write With (AP) Style, Part 1

In writing about this robbery, one of you referred to the robber as a thief. Are those terms interchangeable? No. How do I know that? AP Style.

This is what it says under "burglary, larceny, robbery, theft":

Legal definitions of burglary vary, but in general a burglary involves entering a building (not necessarily by breaking in) and remaining unlawfully with the intention of committing a crime.

Larceny is the legal term for the wrongful taking of proerty. Its nonlegal equivalents are stealing or theft.

Robbery in the legal sense involves the use of violence or threat in committing larceny. In a wider sense it means to plunder or rifle, and may thus be used even if a person was not present: His house was robbed while he was away.

Theft describes a larceny that did not involve threat, violence or plundering.

So, based on that information, was he a robber or a thief? Why or why not?

Robbery -- Write With (AP) Style, Part 2

Is it 11:00 p.m. or 11 p.m. or 11 pm or 11 o'clock?

It's 11 p.m., or maybe 11 o'clock. Under "times":

Use figures except for noon and midnight. Use a colon to separate hours from minutes: 11 a.m., 1 p.m., 3:30 p.m. . . . The construction 4 o'clock is acceptable, but time listings with a.m. or p.m. are preferred.

Is it 24 hours or 24 hrs? Under "time sequences" (right after the listing for "time"!):
Bold
Spell out: 50 hours, 23 minutes, 14 seconds.

In general, do you spell out the number three, or use the digit 3? What about two and 2? Eleven and 11?

We've already gone over these, folks. You tell me.

Robbery -- Four Fatals? Frustrating.

I'm sorry to say we set a new fatal standard for the semester so far: four people fataled this exercise.

Why? Attention to detail, that's why.

One of you cited Ingham County police. The information given to you indicated it was Meridian Township police and Ingham County prosecutors.

Another one of you named the robbery victim as Michael Ernest. His name was actually Michael Ernest Layoux.

And two of you spelled the last name of the robber as Weiss. The information given to you indicated it was Wiess.

Each of these fatals was avoidable. You need to MAKE SURE you are double-checking EVERYTHING you have written against he facts that you have been given. You need to MAKE SURE you are checking ALL information given to you for inconsistencies.

Every time. All the time.

Let's not have another fatal day like Monday, okay?

Robbery -- "The" vs. "A"

Was it THE Haslett convenience store? Or A Haslett convenience store?

I'd say the latter. It probably isn't the only store in town, right?

Is it THE robber, or A robber, in first reference?

Same thing. The robber probably isn't the only one to ever rob anything.

Robbery -- Spell Check Hates You!

Not completely. But I need to remind you, spell check will not catch words that you accidentally use that are spelled correctly.

Like when you said the robber ran through the class. I assume you meant glass.

Or when you said police said is was okay. I assume you want it was okay.

Yes, you should use spell check. But that's not a substitute for reading your copy word-for-word.

Robbbery -- Did you need . . .

. . . to use the clerk's full name of Michael Ernest Layoux?

It's not wrong to use middle names or middle initials, but here's a good rule of thumb: if you feel the name is so common where a middle name is needed to distinguish a person from others with a similar name, then you may want to use a middle name or initial. Like with former MSU football coach John L. Smith.

But if you feel the name is fairly unique, it's less necessary. Like with Omar Sofradzija.

BTW, you may have noticed serial killers or mass murderers or criminals of the highest profile are often referred to with a middle name included (like John Wayne Gacy, Lee Harvey Oswald, ect.). That's because with a crime so heinous, you want to go the extra mile to make sure you're identifying the right guy.

Robbery -- Did you say . . .

. . . it was a brand of Winston cigarettes? Or just cigarettes?

Was the particular brand necesary to the story? Or was it unimportant, other than to give the company a free ad?

Specific brands should be cited if important to the story; like if a Ford Focus crashed into a Hummer. Knowing a teeny-car brand hit a monster-tank brand makes a story more understandable, right?

But in this case, the robber could have asked for Winstons or Camels or whatever. It really wouldn't have made any difference.

It's one thing if you were writing some sort of detailed narrative, where small observations mater in setting mood and color. This wasn't one of those cases. You were just writing a plain ol' daily news story.

I would have left out the brand name.

Robbery -- Who, What, When, WHERE, Why . . .

Did you need to cite the store's street address? Isn't that a basic and helpful identifier of WHERE this happened?

Wouldn't people wonder WHERE? Whether this was near their home? Or was the store they go to?

I'm just sayin'.