Saturday, October 9, 2010

Out Of Class #1 -- Almost Due!

You should be finishing up work on your first out of class story assignment, due Wednesday. Make sure you meet the minimum requirements as noted in the syllabus in terms of length and sourcing.

Also, use the lessons you've learned in class and mentioned in this blog -- including today's blog posts about source attribution, which we will talk about here in a bit.

The deadline is BY the start of class Wednesday, so it has to be to me by 9:10 a.m. that day. You may turn in your story in paper form or electronically in a Word document via email to omars@msu.edu.

Whether you turn in your story by hand or email, be sure to turn in to me your tip sheet by the deadline.

Do the best you can on this assignment. It's just the first big step in your journalistic evolution, so don't sweat it too much. You'll only get better as the class goes along. Keep in mind you will have an opportunity to rewrite the story and improve your assignment grade.

And of course, don't forget: NO FATALS. Double-check everything and assume nothing.

Good luck, everybody.

Thursday, October 7, 2010

Missing: A Roundup

Decent job overall on the take-home assignment. There are some problems to work out that we'll discuss here, but it's nothing that's unusual for a novice journalist.

There was one situation that came up: someone filed their story late. In this case, the person was specifically waiting for responses to questions they emailed me.

Since I never gave explicit instructions on what to do in such instances, I won't fatal this person this time.

Note I said "this time."

In the future, if you have story questions and I do not respond in a manner that is timely to you, finish the story the best you can and put in writing after the story what your question was, and what you had to do in writing your story to work your way around the unanswered question.

If I decide your question was something that a novice journalist couldn't reasonably figure out on their own (such as choosing between two inconsistent spellings of the same name), then you will not be penalized for the omission. If the omission is something I think you should have been able to figure out on your own (such as an attribution matter, where the attribution is included but perhaps you zipped past it by reading your sourcing too quickly), then you will be docked.

Either way, I expect your assignments to be turned in on deadline. No more exceptions from here on out, unless it's a truly bizarre situation.

P.S., another one of you cut it waaaaay too close in turning in the assignment. This person came within 58 seconds of a time fatal.

Please, don't wait until the last minute to send your story. Your comupter can freeze up. Or your Internet connection can go slow. Or other problems might arise. Just like such problems do in professional newsrooms (where, if you hit such problems and miss a deadline, you can face an editor who will yell at you, "Why did you wait until the last f@#%ing minute to file your story, anyway?" Always give yourselves a time cushion of at least a few minutes so you can overcome any unanticipated last-second problems.)

Missing: Ledes Are Waaaaay Too Looooong

Some of you are still penning ledes that are way too long. Ledes that are mushed together with nut grafs. Ledes that are waaaaay over the 32 words or so we're trying to maintain for now.

So, here's a new rule. It's in caps and bold-faced so it's unmistakable:

ALL LEDES FOR PRACTICE STORY AND TEST STORY EXERCISES MUST BE NO MORE THAN 32 WORDS UNTIL FURTHER NOTICE!!!

ANY LEDES IN A PRACTICE STORY OR A TEST STORY THAT EXCEEDS THAT LIMIT WILL BE CONSIDERED A FATAL, AND YOU WILL RECEIVE A ZERO ON THAT EXERCISE.

I'M NOT KIDDING, FOLKS!!!

I'm not doing this to be an ass. But ledes are supposed to be brief and to the point. A lede that's 40 or 50 words is neither brief nor to the point.

And a big part of journalism is decision-making; that is, sorting through endless information and prioritizing and summarizing for the reader what is most important. If I allow you to do runaway ledes, you won't develop good decision-making habits. And that will catch up with you at some point; maybe not in this class, and probably at a time when the stakes for you will be much higher.

So we're not going to let that happen. We're going to work out your bad habits and instill some good habits. And that's gonna start with a 32-word cap on ledes.

(For some of you, it's not even a question of needing to develop a lede; you already have a good lede, but it's mushed together with the nut graf and a supporting graf. We just need to make sure you know where to find the "return" key on your keyboard. Here's a good rule of thumb: if you have a lede -- or any paragraph, for that matter -- that's more than one sentence, take a look and see if it's one unit of thought or one piece of information supporting that unit of thought. If it's more than one unit of any of the above, then split it up into separate grafs.)

If anyone needs ANY help in developing ledes, let's schedule some office hours to work on it. I don't expect you to figure this out on your own, but I do expect you to identify what you're having problems with and seek the appropriate remedial help.

Missing: How Do You Know? (Part 1)

How did you know no more than 100 missing people are victims of foul play? It it because you spoke to each and every missing person?

No. It's because police told you. So you need to attribute that number to something like, police said.

How do you know Sabrina the teen-age run-away ended up in New York, where she prostituted herself? Were you hanging out with her there?

No. You know because she told you. So you needed to attribute that to something like, she said.

How do you know Jason Abare was arrested last month. Were you there when he got busted?

No. You know because he told you. By now, you know what you needed to do.

Pretty much everything not witnessed by you should have some sort of attribution. He said; she said; according to records; whatever.

Make sure you have properly attributed everything in your story. Basically, every paragraph after the lede and nut graf should have some sort of attribution affixed to it.

Missing: Did You . . .

. . . use Sabrina Diaz's last name?

Why? Didn't you promise her that you would not?

If you didn't use her last name, did you tell readers WHY you weren't?

In "Elements of Journalism," we talked about being transparent with readers. Part of that transparency includes telling readers why we aren't fully identifying somebody.

You really needed a disclaimer like . . .

. . . said Sabrina, who spoke on the condition that her last name not be used.

Missing: Did You Notice . . .

. . . the first name of Jason Abare's wife was spelled TWO different ways (Anne/Ann)?

If you did notice, what did you do, and/or what should you have done?

Missing: Write With (AP) Style

On first reference, is it Sergeant Manuel Cortez, or Sgt. Manuel Cortez?

It's Sgt. I know, because I looked in AP Style, under "military titles."

On second reference, is it Sgt. Cortez, or just Cortez?

It's the latter. Under the same:

In subsequent references, do not continue using the title before a name. Use only the last name.

Do you start a sentence with a number expressed in digits? No. Do you spell out "percent" instead of using the symbol? Yes. We went over those AP Style points ALREADY. These repeat mistakes should NOT be cropping back up!

Wednesday, October 6, 2010

Squirrels: Ya Did Good

I saw lots of good stuff in the squirrels exercise. Good structure, nice writing, yadda yadda yay.

No fatals, and everybody scored in the 3-point range. Everybody identified the inconsistency in their source notes -- the double-spelling of a last name, the correct of which was Brookes -- and everybody seemed to understand what they were writing.

Good assignment, folks!

Squirrels: Write Tight

Why say "An Associate English Professor at LCC, Oliver Brookes . . . "

. . . when you could say . . .

"LCC Associate English Professor Oliver Brookes . . . "

Watch your word order and look for efficiencies. Quite often "an" or "at" or such words are unnecessary.

Save a couple of words; save a tree; save the world.

Squirrels: No First Person!

This was one of your grafs:

But why are the squirrels attacking our cars?

That's a no-no. Avoid first-person construction; as journalists, we are not part of the stories we write. So there is no "our" or "us" or "I" (unless, of course, a first person account is precisely the specialized type of story you're working on. Which you won't be in this class).

So what to do? Consider your story subjects. It's LCC, right?

So, why not say, But why are squirrels attacking cars at LCC?

Squirrels: Write With (AP) Style

Is it Lansing Community College, or LCC?

Let's look at AP Style, first under "abbreivations and acronyms." I admit, it's confusing gobbledygook here. But this is the general rule of thumb: spell out on first reference, use the acronym or another generic abbreviations (such as "the college") in subsequent references.

Regarding the latter, check "second references" in AP Style.

Squirrels: Nut Grafs Are Driving You Nuts

Some of you are having problems with the concept of a nut graf. A nut graf is generally a paragraph that flows the lede and builds upon it, allowing for a seamless transition into te body of the story.
Bold
The sequence is like this:

The lede hits the most basic and essential elements of the story.

The nut graf expands and elaborates upon the lede.

Then you start with details supporting the lede.

Here's a good lede/nut graf/body sequence from one of youze:

A recent rash of car problems at Lansing Community College is being blamed on one particular group of culprits: squirrels.

In recent weeks, college officials have received several complaints from staff members regarding damage to their cars that, in some cases, have resulted in several hundred dollars worth of repairs.

Associate professor of English Oliver Brookes said he made an unpleasant discovery while trying to determine the cause of a faulty headlight when he opened the hood of his van.

"There was a big squirrels' nest in the corner where the light wires were," Brookes said.

See the flow here?

Squirrels: How Do You Know? (Part 2)

How do you know Brookes spent $184 to get his car's wiring replaced?

Were you there when he had the wiring replaced? No.

Did you pay for the repair bill? No.

So, how do you know?

It's because he said so, right?

So, why not let readers know your sourcing? Brookes said he spent $184 to get his car's wiring replaced?

How do you know Kasparov was driving home one night when her car fritzed out? Because she said! So add "she said" as attribution.

How do you know how her mechanic found squirrels under the hood? Because she said!

Pretty much everything not witnessed by you should have some sort of attribution. He said; she said; according to records; whatever.

Make sure you have properly attributed everything in your story. Basically, every paragraph after the lede and nut graf should have some sort of attribution affixed to it.

Tuesday, October 5, 2010

Attribution: Paraphrases versus quotes

In the attribution exercise, many of you changed paraphrased sections into quotes, by expanding quoted areas from this:

If you knew how meat was made, you'd probably "lose your lunch," she said.

. . . to this:

"If you knew how meat was made, you'd probably lose your lunch," she said.

Bad move. I don't know if maybe you misunderstood the assignment or not, but either way I'd like to be clear: you can turn a quote into a paraphrase, but you cannot turn a paraphrase into a quote. The ONLY things inside quotation marks are the words that actually came out of someone's mouths, exactly as those words were said.

If you're not sure, then simply paraphrase. Nothing inside a quotation mark should be a guess.

Many of you made the same mistake by turning this:

"People think we make $3 million or $5 million a year." They don't realize that most athletes make only $500,000 the ballplayer said.

. . . into this . . .

"People think we make $3 million or $5 million a year. They don't realize that most athletes make only $500,000," the ballplayer said.

. . . when this was the correct outcome:

"People think we make $3 million or $5 million a year" and don't realize that most athletes make only $500,000, the ballplayer said.

Finally, don't change what is within quotes if you are quoting a document. It should appear exactly as it does in the document. One of you changed this:

"Your food stamps will be stopped effective March 1 because we received notice that you passed away . . . " said a letter . . .

. . . to this:

"Your food stamps will be stopped, effective March 1, because we received notice that you passed away . . . " said a letter . . .

If this were a conversation, it wouldn't change the meaning to add the commas. It wouldn't change the spoken word. But here you are quoting the WRITTEN word. You are changing it. Don't do that!

Test ledes: a quick rundown

Here are some highlights from the test ledes exercise:

>>> Watch what you say

Is this right?

East Lansing school officials have unveiled a new program today . . .

Actually, it's less clear than it could be. The unveiling was today, not the new program. It would have been more on point to say this:

East Lansing school officials today unveiled a new program . . .

>>> Quote only quotes

One of you wrote that the tradition of fire poles . . .

. . . will be "extinguished" sometime next year.

I know what you were trying to do: be cute. You put quotations around a pun. But we don't do that in journalism. Quotes go around what somebody actually said ONLY.

Nothing wrong with puns. Just find another way to be punny.

>>> Watch the fatals.

Sorry to say we had some. One person put the location as Lansing, when it was East Lansing. Another person reversed the first and last names of a source. These are all fatals. And all are easily preventable, as long as you take sufficient time to note detail and double-check work.

Avoiding fatals is like avoiding death in a car accident. Do the little things all the time -- look both ways before crossing a street, wear your seat belt, ect. -- and the odds that you'll wreck shrink to a tiny ratio. Overlook these fundamental actions, and your odds get worse.

Controversial: Is this a lede . . .

. . . or a lede and nut graf smushed together?

Four years after promising to tear down an old and potentially hazardous water tank near Santana Boulevard, the Lansing City Council has now found an alternate option to their problem. In a 4-3 vote, the council approved a motion last night to sell the tank to President of Alladdin Paints William Krueger, who offered to repaint and clean it for $50,000.

Let's break it up:

Four years after promising to tear down an old and potentially hazardous water tank near Santana Boulevard, the Lansing City Council has now found an alternate option to their problem.

In a 4-3 vote, the council approved a motion last night to sell the tank to President of Alladdin Paints William Krueger, who offered to repaint and clean it for $50,000.

Which reader better? Which flows better? Which is less cluttered?

Quite often, the easiest way to identify whether you're smushing together grafs is this: is your lede more than one sentence? If so, it may have a nut graf glued to it.

Controversial: Write with (AP) style

Is it Santana Boulevard or Santana Blvd.?

It's Boulevard. In AP Style under "addresses":

Use the abbreviations Ave., Blvd. and St. only with a numbered address: 1600 Pennsylvania Ave. Spell them out and capitalize when part of a formal street name without a number: Pennsylvania Avenue.

In first reference, is it Mayor Datoli or Mayor Bubbles Datoli?

It's the latter. Under "names":

In general, use last names only on second reference.

Is it the East Lansing Fire Chief or the East Lansing fire chief?

Under "titles":

In general, confine capitalization to formal titles used directly before an individual's name . . . lowercase and spell out titles when they are not used with an individual's name.

Is it $6 million or 6 million dollars? We've been through this one before, folks.

Check your AP style!

Controversial: Transition strong

Watch offering empty sentences that say nothing, especially in transitions. Like with ledes, transitions should identify what is important, relevant or interesting to people.

Here was a weak transition:

One of the four male members of last year's team, Jacob Stevens, spoke at the school board meeting. Stevens sounded off about the unfairness of the male players being banned from the sport.

"Spoke at the school board meeting" essentially says nothing. Why not remove that passage and merge the two sentences, like this:

One of the four male members of last year's team, Jacob Stevens, sounded off about the unfairness of the male players being banned from the sport.

See?

Controversial: It's SAID, I said.

It's not "Krueger believes." It's "Krueger SAID."

It's not "Krueger noted." It's "Krueger SAID."

It's not "Krueger says." It's "Krueger SAID."

It's not "Masters bets money." It's "Masters SAID."

You can't say "said" enough.

Controversial: grafs are too big!

Paragraph structure in journalism is very particular. It's all about small grafs.

In many of your stories, I highlighted logical places where paragraph breaks should have been places. These are the L-shaped symbols I have marked at the start of some sentences.

In general, you should limit grafs to ONE main point OR just ONE supporting fact per graf. Generally, that will mean many paragraphs will consist of just a single sentence.

For example, let's look at this passage:

Jacob Stevens, an East Lansing High School senior and now former member of their field hockey team told the school board he doesn’t think this is fair. “Not every guy wants to play football, basketball, or baseball,” Stevens said. “If we can’t play with girls, we wouldn’t be able to play.” Though field hockey is a popular sport for both men and women in other countries, Stevens says there are just not enough boys interested in the area to create their own team.

Really, this is better broken up along these lines:

Jacob Stevens, an East Lansing High School senior and now former member of their field hockey team told the school board he doesn’t think this is fair.

“Not every guy wants to play football, basketball, or baseball,” Stevens said. “If we can’t play with girls, we wouldn’t be able to play.”

Though field hockey is a popular sport for both men and women in other countries, Stevens says there are just not enough boys interested in the area to create their own team.


That might look weird to you, but it's okay. The structure is so that it's easy for readers to identify single points or solitary pieces of evidence. And it makes it much easier for editors to edit your story on deadline -- all they need to do is pull a graf here and move a graf there to touch up your story, as opposed to having to rewrite passages altogether.